pubs.acs.org/JAFC Published on Web 06/14/2010 © 2010 American Chemical Society
7762 J. Agric. Food Chem. 2010, 58, 7762–7769
DOI:10.1021/jf100917w
Influence of Ionic Complexation on Release Rate Profiles from
Multiple Water-in-Oil-in-Water (W/O/W) Emulsions
MARIE BONNET,
†
MAUD CANSELL,*
,†
FRE
´
DE
´
RIC PLACIN,
†
ELISABETH DAVID-BRIAND,
§
MARC ANTON,
§
AND FERNANDO LEAL-CALDERON
†
†
Universite´ Bordeaux 1, TREFLE UMR CNRS 8508, ENSCBP, 16 avenue Pey Berland, 33607 Pessac,
France, and
§
UR1268 Biopolym eres Interactions Assemblages, Equipe Interfaces et Syst emes Disperse´s,
INRA, 44360 Nantes Cedex 3, France
Water-in-oil-in-water (W/O/W) double emulsions were prepared, and the kinetics of release of
magnesium ions from the internal to the external water phase was followed. Different chelating
agents (phosvitin and gluconate) were used to bind magnesium within the prospect of improving the
ion retention in the internal aqueous droplets. Magnesium release was monitored for 1 month of
storage, for each formulation, with and without chelation, at two storage temperatures (4 and 25 °C).
Leakage occurred without film rupturing (coalescence) and was mainly due to entropically driven
diffusion/permeation phenomena. The experimental results revealed a clear correlation between the
effectiveness of chelating agents to delay the delivery and their binding capacity characterized by
the equilibrium affinity constant. The kinetic data (percent released versus time curves) were
interpreted within the framework of a kinetic model based on diffusion and taking into account
magnesium chelation.
KEYWORDS: W/O/W emulsions; sustained release; chelating agent; release mechanisms; diffusion/
permeation
INTRODUCTION
Recently, there has been increasing interest in the development
of multiple or double emulsions, for example, water-in-oil-in-
water (W/O/W) and oil-in-water-in-oil (O/W/O). W/O/W emul-
sions consist of small water droplets dispersed in larger oil
globules, which are themselves dispersed in an aqueous contin-
uous phase. Numerous studies have shown that W/O/W emul-
sions provide a high capacity of entrapment and protection of the
encapsulated species toward degradation. The compartmented
structure allows the introduction of incompatible substances into
the same system and subsequent sustained release ( 1 -8 ). Because
of their encapsulation and protection efficiency, W/O/W emul-
sions are potentially suitable materials for applications in various
domains such as cosmetics, pharmaceutics, and foods. In this
latter domain, double emulsions provide a number of potential
benefits over conventional emulsions, such as reduction of fat
content ( 9 ), taste masking, and protection of labile ingredients or
sensitive probiotics ( 8 ). Double emulsions of the W/O/W type are
generally stabilized by a couple of surface-active species following
the empirical Bancroft rule: one is water-soluble to stabilize the oil
globules in water and the other is oil-soluble to stabilize the
internal aqueous droplets dispersed in oil. Nevertheless, there
have been many difficulties associated with preparing this type of
multiple emulsion with sufficient stability for commercial utiliza-
tion, due to coalescence or due to diffusion of water molecules
and of the whole set of hydrophilic solutes from the internal
aqueous phase to the bulk aqueous phase or vice versa ( 10 ).
During years of investigations to improve stability and to control
sustained release of active species, short surfactant molecules
have been progressively replaced by polymeric emulsifiers. Poly-
meric amphiphilic molecules, synthetic or naturally occurring
ones, are known to impart better emulsion stability, to ensure
better encapsulation and controlled release of the encapsulated
species than low molecular weight surfactants ( 11 -15 ).
In this paper, we addressed a common issue that arises with
potential uses of double emulsions: achieving sufficient stability
for commercial applications. This issue is relevant in all of the
sectors that may potentially use double emulsions (food industry,
pharmacy, and cosmetics). The main objective of the present
study was to develop a novel strategy based on the complexation
(chelation) of ionic encapsulated species to improve retention in
W/O/W emulsions. Magnesium (Mg
2þ
) was used not only as a
model species to probe the release mechanism but also as a
valuable compound for food supplementation. Indeed, magne-
sium plays a role as a physiologic modulator affecting muscular
contraction, cardiovascular function, and nerve impulse trans-
mission. Due to a change in nutrition habits, the daily intake in
magnesium is lower than the recommended value. Thus, magne-
sium supplementation of food could be an alternative to prevent
magnesium deficiency and its clinical disorders, for example,
hypertension, cardiovascular diseases, muscular weakness, and
diarrhea. However, magnesium addition in foods can induce
chemical degradations and protein aggregation and generate an
unpleasant taste. These drawbacks could be avoided or at least
reduced by encapsulation. In recent studies, we have studied the
*Author to whom correspondence should be addressed [phone 33
(0)5 40 00 38 19; fax 33 (0)5 56 37 03 36; e-mail mcansell@enscbp.fr].