Breast Cancer Research and Treatment 73: 189–197, 2002.
© 2002 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
Report
Quantitative assessment of the clavicle radiostructure as a tool for
estimation of the osteopathic effect of breast cancer chemotherapy
Krzysztof Le´ sniewski-Kmak
1
, Krzysztof W. Zieli´ nski
2
, and Cezary Szczylik
1
1
Clinic of Oncology, Central Clinical Hospital, Military University School of Medicine, Warszawa;
2
Department
of Clinical Pathomorphology, Military University School of Medicine, L´ od´ z, Poland
Key words: bone, breast cancer, chemotherapy side effects, image analysis, methotrexate, osteoporosis, radiometry
Summary
Radiological structure (trabeculation) of the clavicle was quantitatively evaluated using the chest X-ray images
obtained in 36 pre-menopausal women subjected to CMF (cyclophosphamide, methotrexate, fluorouracil) chemo-
therapy. For comparison, the values of the quantitative radiostructural indices were estimated from the X-ray
images obtained in 65 age-matched pre-menopausal healthy women and 19 post-menopausal women with clin-
ically confirmed osteoporosis. For the analyses, the high-quality routine chest P–A films were used in which the
central segment of the clavicle was well visualised. Evaluation of the skeletal radiostructure was carried out using
the original software developed by K.W. Zieli´ nski which, in addition to standardising the quality of the image,
calculated the structural density as well as the arrangement and mean thickness of the trabeculae. The results
demonstrate in a reproducible way that structural density and mean thickness of the clavicular trabeculae were
significantly (p< 0.01) lower in pre-menopausal, CMF-treated and post-menopausal, osteoporotic patients than in
healthy, control women. Likewise, the relative radiological density of the clavicle was reduced in the former two
groups of women as compared to their control counterparts and the difference approached statistical significance.
When the X-ray films were compared in each breast cancer patient before and after the chemotherapy the values
of all the three parameters were decreased in up to 86% of the treated patients. Overall, the obtained results
demonstrate the significant osteopathic side effect of the CMF chemotherapy in pre-menopausal breast cancer
patients.
Introduction
Although the first study on the effects of methotrex-
ate on calcium metabolism was published as early
as in 1965 [1], osteopathy is still one of the less
appreciated complications of the anti-tumour chemo-
therapy. In view of the high incidence of breast cancer
worldwide and the fact that the chemotherapy often
contains methotrexate [2], we aimed in the present
study to estimate the effect of the adjuvant therapy ac-
cording to the Bonadonna CMF (cyclophosphamide,
methotrexate, fluorouracil) regimen on the morpho-
logical structure of claviles of the treated patients.
Indeed, the radiologically defined morphological ar-
chitecture of bones is responsible for their mech-
anical strength and is regarded as the most important
criterion in the diagnosis of osteoporosis; this para-
meter, however, should not be mistaken for the mineral
density of bones which is assessed by densitometric
methods.
Material
For the studies, 134 high-quality routine chest P–A
films were used in which the central segment of the
clavicle was well visualised with no overlapping by
other bone structures.
The films were obtained from the three groups of
women: (1) ‘chemotherapy group’ consisting of 36
pre-menopausal (mean age 44.6 years; age range 32–
50 years), stage I and II breast cancer patients; the
X-ray tests were performed between 6 and 24 months
(mean 10.5 months) after completion of the adjuvant