116-5107/90/3601-0043$02.00
ASTROINTESTINAL ENDOSCOPY
opyright © 1990 by the American Society for Gastrointestinal Endoscopy
Jse of ethanol-induced tumor necrosis to
Jalliate dysphagia in patients with
3sophagogastric cancer
J. J. Payne-James, FRCS, FRCSEd, R. C. Spiller, MD, MRCP
J. J. Misiewicz, FRCP, D. B. A. Silk, MD, FRCP
London, United Kingdom
:Ieven patients with dysphagia caused by inoperable, unresectable, or recurrent
cancer were treated by endoscopic injection of ethanol (with or
without per-oral dilation) to induce tumor necrosis. Prior to treatment, patients had
a mean dysphagia grade of 3. After one treatment, dysphagia grade had
improved to a mean of 1.5. An optimum dysphagia grade (mean, 0.9) was
achieved after a mean of 1.6 injection treatments. Treatments were repeated as
symptoms recurred, with a mean period between repeat treatments of 32 days
(median, 26). There were no complications associated with ethanol-induced tumor
necrosis (ETN). Mean patient survival was 140 days (median, 109). These results
suggest that ETN has considerable potential for palliation of malignant dysphagia
in selected patients. (Gastrointest Endosc 1990;36:43-46)
Prognosis for patients with carcinomas of the
esophagus and stomach is poor, and most patients are
beyond cure by the time the diagnosis has been made.
Palliation of symptoms, predominantly dysphagia, is
therefore often the main aim of treatment. Surgery
offers the possibility of complete relief of dysphagia
with an acceptably low mortality rate,1 even within
the elderly population.
2
There are, however, three groups of patients, those
with inoperable tumors, those with unresectable tu-
mors, and those with recurrent tumors, in whom sur-
gery is not possible and for whom an effective method
of palliation is needed. It has been stated that the
ideal palliative technique should be "quick, safe, pain-
less, needing only a short inpatient stay, and a low
complication rate.,,3 To this list could be added, "easily
repeatable, but only needing repetition infrequently,"
as regrowth of tumor and recurrence of symptoms is
common. Four main methods of palliation of malig-
nant dysphagia are available, each with differing ad-
vantages and disadvantages. Intubation of the malig-
Received December 1, 1988. For revision April 3, 1989. Accepted July
19, 1990.
From the Department of Gastroenterology and Nutrition, Central
Middlesex Hospital, London, United Kingdom.
Reprint requests: J. J. Payne-James, FRCS, Department of GaBtro-
enterology and Nutrition, Central Middlesex Hospital, Acton Lane,
London NWlO 7NS, United Kingdom.
VOLUME 36, NO.1, 1990
nant obstruction, by either a surgical or an endoscopic
technique, has been shown to be effective in improving
quality of life, albeit with an associated morbidity and
mortality.4,5 Per-oral endoscopic dilation by itself ful-
fills most of the criteria for an ideal palliative tech-
nique, but may require repeating on many occasions,
sometimes on a weekly basis.
G
,7 Radiation therapy is
predominantly suitable for squamous cell carcinomas,
and despite increasingly sophisticated techniques
(some requiring general anesthesia
8
) the degree of
palliation may not be markedly different from other
methods.
9
Recent studies have demonstrated the use-
fulness of laser,1O-12 but this equipment is not readily
available in a majority of hospitals at present. Despite
the variety of palliative techniques, it is apparent that
the optimal therapy has not yet been found for this
difficult group of patients. Clearly it is desirable to
keep hospital attendances and length of inpatient stay
to a minimum. Encouraging results using dehydrated
alcohol to cause necrosis and destruction of gastric
cancer have been reported.
13
Injection of sclerosant
solutions into the esophagus for the treatment of
esophageal varices has become an established proce-
dure that has been performed on an outpatient ba-
SiS.
14
,15 The possibility was considered that malignant
dysphagia related to esophageal or gastric cardia neo-
plasms could be palliated by direct injection of tumor
with alcohol via an endoscope, thereby inducing tumor
43