1
Abstract—Nuclear power is one of the main electricity
production sources in Sweden today. Maintenance management
is one tool for reducing the costs for operation of a power plant.
Driving forces for cost-efficiency has pushed the development of
new methods for maintenance planning and optimization
forward. Reliability Centered Asset Management (RCAM) is one
of these new approaches, and maintenance optimization is one
way to perform quantitative analysis which is a feature of
RCAM. This paper proposes a model for opportunistic
maintenance optimization where replacement schedules for shaft
seals in feed-water pump systems in nuclear power plants are
constructed. The feed-water pump system is important for the
availability of the entire nuclear power plant. Results show that
the optimization model is dependent on e.g. the discount interest
and a limit for when the optimal solution goes from non-
opportunistic to opportunistic is calculated. The circumstances
for which opportunistic maintenance could be used have been
investigated given different values of discount rates and
remaining life at start of the planning period.
Index Terms—Maintenance management, nuclear power,
opportunistic maintenance, optimization, reliability.
I. INTRODUCTION
sustainable energy system must involve several electrical
production sources. Local conditions are decisive for
determining the electrical production system that should be
dominating. About 90% of the electricity production in
Sweden is today from nuclear power and hydro power,
however there are large increase in renewable energy
production from e.g. wind.
This work was supported by the Swedish Centre of Excellence in Electric
Power Systems (EKC2) at KTH.
Julia Nilsson is with the School of Electrical Engineering at the Royal
Institute of Technology (KTH) in Stockholm, Sweden (e-mail:
julia.nilsson@ee.kth.se ).
Adam Wojciechowski, Ann-Brith Strömberg and Michael Patriksson are
with the Department of Mathematical Sciences at Chalmers University of
Technology and the Department of Mathematical Sciences at the University of
Gothenburg, in Göteborg, Sweden (e-mail: wojcadam@chalmers.se ,
anstr@chalmers.se , mipat@chalmers.se ).
Lina Bertling is with the Department of Energy and Environment, and
Division of Electrical Power Engineering at Chalmers University of
Technology, in Göteborg, Sweden (e-mail: lina.bertling@chalmers.se ).
One benefit with nuclear power is that the operation is almost
free from climate-affecting pollution. A major disadvantage is
the waste and its final storage. Nuclear power is associated
with several risks. Risk is defined as the probability of failure
multiplied by the consequences of failure. The probability of
failure is a reliability measure. The performance of operation
and maintenance must always be safe and structured.
Reliability-centered maintenance (RCM) is a structured
approach that focuses on reliability when planning
maintenance [1].
The deregulation of the electric power system and the
introduction of the electricity market have generally led to
lower investments in maintenance. As a result, new
approaches
for maintenance management have been developed, such as
Reliability Centered Asset Management (RCAM) [2]. RCAM
is a development of RCM into a quantitative approach with
the aim to relate preventive maintenance to total maintenance
cost and system reliability.
This paper focuses on RCAM using a maintenance
optimization approach for nuclear power plants. Moreover, an
opportunistic approach is used. A general optimization model,
applied for example to the replacement of components in
aircraft engines [3], is used to gain a maintenance schedule for
replacements of subcomponents. The system observed is the
feed-water pump system, which is a system in the nuclear
power plant critical for the availability of the plant. This
system is necessary for maintaining a stable level of water in
the reactor, and it must therefore keep a steady flow in the
tank. Minimizing costs for replacing shaft seals and costs for
production loss would gain an optimal maintenance schedule.
As a case study, the Boiling Water Reactors (BWR) at
Forsmark nuclear power plant are studied.
II. THEORY
A. Availability
Availability is an important measure of reliability, and has
several different definitions. One definition is found in [4]:
An Opportunistic Maintenance Optimization
Model for Shaft Seals in Feed-Water Pump
Systems in Nuclear Power Plants
J. Nilsson, Graduate Student Member, IEEE, A. Wojciechowski, A-B. Strömberg, M. Patriksson and
L. Bertling, Senior Member, IEEE.
A
Paper accepted for presentation at 2009 IEEE Bucharest Power Tech Conference, June 28th - July 2nd, Bucharest, Romania
978-1-4244-2235-7/09/$25.00 ©2009 IEEE