6236-001-005.3d Pages: [133–158] Date: [April 7, 2012] Time: [18:17]
State, Migrants, and the Negotiation of
Second-Generation Citizenship in the
Israeli Diaspora
Nir Cohen
Bar Ilan University
Using second-generation Israeli migrants in the United States as a
case study, this article explores one unusual site in which the politics
of diasporic citizenship unfold. It examines the North American chap-
ter of the Israeli Scouts (Tzofim Tzabar) as an arena of negotiation
between representatives of the sending state apparatus and migrants
over the meaning (and practices) of citizenship outside national terri-
tory. This quotidian space is important to migrants’ contestation with
the state concerning their claims for a form of membership that is nei-
ther territorial nor contingent upon the fulfillment of traditional civic
duties (e.g., military service). Challenging the state-supported model
of republicanism, in which presence in territory and the fulfillment of
a predetermined set of civic duties are preconditions for citizenship,
Israeli migrants advocate instead an arrangement based on a strong
cultural identity and a revised set of diaspora-based material prac-
tices of support.
Keywords: sending state, migrants, second generation, diasporic citi-
zenship, Israel
The exponential growth in volume and intensity of cross-border
mobility has significantly challenged the territorial foundation of the
state (Castles and Davidson 2000; Jacobson 1996; Joppke 1999). The
emergence of sizable ethno-national, ethnic, and religious diasporas
has loosened the traditional, post-Westphalian symmetrical relations
between state, territory, and nation, subjecting the former to numerous
claims for cultural recognition, rights, and benefits from these and
other so-called deterritorialized groups (Soysal 1994). Such quests have
challenged states and, in some cases, altered classic forms of national,
territorial citizenship (Bauböck 1994). As Aihwa Ong (2006) argued,
“The difference between having and not having citizenship is becoming
Diaspora 16:1/2 2007
Nir Cohen, “State, Migrants, and the Negotiation of Second-Generation
Citizenship in the Israeli Diaspora,” Diaspora 16, 1/2 (2007): 133–158.
© 2012 Diaspora: a journal of transnational studies.
133