Reversible switching of the first hyperpolarisability of an NLO-active
donor–acceptor molecule based on redox interconversion of the
octamethylferrocene donor unit
Michael Malaun,
a
Zoe R. Reeves,
a
Rowena L. Paul,
a
John C. Jeffery,
a
Jon A. McCleverty,*
a
Michael D. Ward,*
a
Inge Asselberghs,
b
Koen Clays
b
and Andr´ e Persoons
b
a
School of Chemistry,University of Bristol, Cantock’s Close, Bristol, UK BS8 1TS. E-mail: mike.ward@bristol.ac.uk;
jon.mccleverty@bristol.ac.uk
b
Laboratory of Chemical and Biological Dynamics, Center for Research on Molecular Electronics and Photonics,
University of Leuven, Celestijnenlaan 200D, B-3001 Leuven, Belgium
Received (in Cambridge, UK) 5th October 2000, Accepted 15th November 2000
First published as an Advance Article on the web 15th December 2000
Compound 1, containing an octamethylferrocene donor
linked to a nitrothiophene acceptor via an ethenyl linker,
shows a static first hyperpolarisability b
0
of 95(±10) 3 10
230
esu, which is reduced to 10(±2) 3 10
230
esu on oxidation of
the octamethylferrocene unit; this provides for a simple
redox-based switching of the NLO characteristics of the
compound.
Compounds displaying non-linear optical (NLO) properties are
of considerable interest because of their possible applications in
the emerging technologies of optoelectronic and photonic
devices.
1
Second-order NLO effects, including second-har-
monic generation, and especially electro-optic modulation are
important in interfacing massive amounts of electronic data to
wideband optical communication. At the molecular level, the
efficiency for electro-optic modulation is determined by the
second-order non-linear polarisability, also called the first
hyperpolarisability, b. A large value of b is generally associated
with molecules which have a donor/conjugated bridge/acceptor
(D-p-A) structure, such that there is a long-range charge-
transfer transition from one end to the other and consequently a
substantial difference between the ground-state and excited-
state dipole moments.
The ability to switch the NLO response of a molecule ‘on’
and ‘off’ reversibly by a simple controllable perturbation would
add significant value to the utility of NLO molecules, from the
point of view of developing molecular photonic devices whose
properties can be switched by modifying one of the component
parts.
2
Despite the large number of molecules with large first
hyperpolarisabilities, there are remarkably few examples in
which such reversible switching has been demonstrated. Of
these the majority depend on isomerisation or tautomerisation
of the molecule, such that the nature of the conjugated bridge
linking the donor and acceptor termini undergoes a substantial
change.
3
A more appealing method of controlling the second-
order NLO response of a molecule would be a reversible redox
change, in which either the donor (D) unit is oxidised or the
acceptor (A) unit is reduced. The result in either case would be
a loss of the charge-transfer capability and a consequent drop in
the hyperpolarisability b.
2
To date there is a single example of
this in the literature, from the group of Coe, comprising a
{Ru(NH
3
)
5
}
2+
donor linked to a viologen-like acceptor; the
value of b decreased by an order of magnitude on one-electron
oxidation of the Ru terminus. Subsequent re-reduction of the Ru
terminus completely restored the SHG properties of the
compound.
4
We describe here a new molecule for second-order NLO
applications (1) which contains an octamethylferrocene donor
unit and a nitrothiophene acceptor, linked by an ethenyl bridge.
The reversible octamethylferrocene–octamethylferrocenium
couple, at modest potential, provides an ideal route for redox-
based switching of the hyperpolarisability. Compounds which
contain ferrocene units as the electron donor, with a single
conjugated side-arm linked to an acceptor unit, have been
exceptionally popular for studying SHG in the last decade.
5
The
redox activity of the ferrocene donor unit however has not until
now been exploited for switching purposes; use of the
octamethylferrocene unit in 1 will both enhance its electron-
donor properties compared to ferrocene, and will reduce the
redox potential to make redox-based switching more facile.
Compound 1 was prepared in good yield† by a Wittig
reaction between 1A,2,2A,3,3A,4,4A,5-octamethylferrocenylme-
thyltriphenylphosphonium bromide
6
and 5-nitro-2-thiophene-
carbaldehyde in tetrahydrofuran (THF); the crystal structure is
in Fig. 1.‡ The cyclopentadienyl ring of the donor, the ethenyl
bridge, and the nitrothiophene acceptor are essentially coplanar
which will clearly optimise end-to-end charge-transfer via the
conjugated system. The electronic spectrum in CH
2
Cl
2
(Fig. 2)
Fig. 1 Crystal structure of 1 together with selected bond distances. The
structure of the complex cation of [1]
+
(PF
6
)·CH
2
Cl
2
is essentially identical,
and the bond distances for this are given in square parentheses after the
corresponding value for 1. Fe–C (average) 2.05 [2.10], N(1)–O(1) 1.242(4)
[1.232(3)], N(1)–O(2) 1.228(4) [1.235(3)], N(1)–C(1) 1.423(4) [1.428(3)],
C(1)–C(2) 1.354(5) [1.356(4)], C(2)–C(3) 1.405(4) [1.401(3)], C(3)–C(4)
1.377(4) [1.379(3)], C(1)–S(1) 1.719(3) [1.718(2)], C(4)–S(1) 1.738(3)
[1.731(2)], C(4)–C(5) 1.442(4) [1.446(3)], C(5)–C(6) 1.348(4) [1.336(3)],
C(6)–C(7) 1.449(4) [1.461(3)] Å.
Fig. 2 Electronic spectra of 1 and [1]
+
(PF
6
) in CH
2
Cl
2
.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2001
DOI: 10.1039/b008056j Chem. Commun., 2001, 49–50 49