Chapter 25
Evolving Bodies: Mapping (Trans)Gender
Identities in Refugee Law
Senthorun Raj
Introduction
Despite the increasing extension of protection obligations to sexual minorities, the international
jurisprudence has yet to resolve the question of recognizing the queer mobilities of asylum
claims on the basis of gender identity or expression. While the administrative and judicial
decisions in anglophone jurisdictions evince a growing trend towards recognizing transgender
or transsexual asylum-seekers, there remains considerable conceptual uncertainty about how
this ‘particular social group’ (PSG) should be defined and about what ought to be considered
as a ‘well-founded fear of persecution’ (UNHCR, 2010, p. 14). Despite the expansive analysis
on sexual orientation-related asylum claims, current academic research and policy debates in
relation to (trans)gender-identity refugees remain largely in their infancy. While domestic laws
governing refugee determinations vary across jurisdictions, there remains little consistency
about how the Convention definition is applied. Focusing on the historic US case Hernandez-
Montiel v Immigration and Naturalization Service [2000], this chapter examines the
definition of a PSG; the quantification of persecution; and how the nexus of gender identity-
related harms is recognized to consider the queer mobilities possible for both refugees and the
laws and processes that govern them.
This chapter opens by examining how the veracity of gender-identity claims is assessed
against immutable qualities or personal psychological narratives of gender dysphoria from
early childhood. In quantifying persecution, decision-makers’ preference for identifying
persecution in terms of state actors often obscures the complex domestic and familial contexts
in which gender-diverse individuals experience violence and social opprobrium. The chapter
concludes by seizing on some of these juridical and administrative limitations, and examines
how consideration of gender identity-related asylum claims enables us to rethink the legal
mobility of the UN Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees (1951) and the 1967 Protocol
to offer protection to displaced individuals Comparing the differing interpretations of the
Convention, this chapter reviews a limited number of publicly available administrative and
judicial decisions from the USA and Australia to indicate some ways in which refugee
Browne, Kath, and Gavin Brown. The Routledge Research Companion to Geographies of Sex and Sexualities, edited by Kath Browne, and Gavin Brown, Taylor and Francis, 2016. ProQuest Ebook Central, .
Created from usyd on 2016-11-20 12:48:20.
Copyright © 2016. Taylor and Francis. All rights reserved.