Successful early mobilization of major cuff repair using a
suture post
Robert N. Atkinson, MBBS, MA, DCH, FRACS(Orth), Andrew S. Comley, MBBS, John Van Essen, MBBS,
Peter J. Hallam, FRCS(Orth), Neil Ashwood, FRCS(Orth), and Quentin A. Fogg, BSc(Hons),
Adelaide, South Australia
Repair of massive rotator cuff tears in the elderly can
be challenging because of degenerative, retracted,
and contracted tendons producing an extensive defect.
The quality of the tendon and particularly the bone of
the proximal humerus is an inherent weakness in the
repaired construct. We report a method that secures
the rotator cuff to a fixation post placed in cortical
bone at the surgical neck of the humerus, bypassing
the weakest point. This is an evolution of techniques
designed to fix to the greater tuberosity. We reviewed
32 repairs (16 men and 14 women; mean age, 68
years) with a minimum of 2 years’ follow-up (mean,
4.3 years). Constant scores improved from a mean of
27.9 preoperatively to 78.2 postoperatively. Pain
scores improved from 8.2 to 1.9, with 87% of patients
being satisfied with the results of surgery. This is a ro-
bust construct that is easily learned and able to solve a
technical problem. (J Shoulder Elbow Surg 2006;15:
183-187.)
M assive tears have a diameter of greater than 5 cm
and account for a third of rotator cuff injuries leading
to pain and restricted function.
1,13
In the working age
group, tears reduce function, and in the elderly age
group, tears cause loss of independence.
9
Acute
large or massive rotator cuff tears can result in a
sudden loss of shoulder function with disabling pain
and are often resistant to nonoperative treatment.
12
More commonly, massive tears can present in an
acute-on-chronic fashion with a sudden exacerbation
of symptoms in a shoulder that has exhibited preex-
isting degeneration and tearing.
15
Open treatment of
such tears with fixation of the tendon into a bone
trough in the greater tuberosity by transosseous su-
tures has been a standard approach with good results
in more than 85% of patients.
4
In elderly patients,
however, the cuff tissue is edematous, friable, and
retracted. The hypertrophied greater tuberosity tends
to be osteopenic, leading to an inherent weakness in
most repair constructs. Multiple studies evaluating the
in vitro strength of the tissues involved in rotator cuff
repair have shown the bone-suture interface to be a
significant weak link in the construct, with the bone
failing at lower tensile loads than the suture.
3,10,12,21
Better methods of soft-tissue fixation to bone have
been developed, including suture anchors, but even
these have shown variable results.
20
Soft tissues can
be fixed with sutures, staples, or screws.
17
Screws
with spiked washers or metallic soft-tissue plates have
been shown to have superior holding power.
8
In this
study, at the time of surgery, all shoulders underwent
arthroscopic acromioplasty and evaluation that estab-
lished the size of the rotator cuff tear before proceed-
ing to open surgery. This confirmed the completeness
of the acromioplasty and arthroscopic assessment of
the tear.
We present the results for a technique that uses a
screw (designed for hamstring anterior cruciate re-
construction) inserted into the strong metaphyseal
bone at the surgical neck of the humerus bypassing
the osteoporotic and hypertrophic greater tuberosity.
This method provides secure fixation of the rotator
cuff, allowing early mobilization.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Over a 3-year period, 32 shoulders in 30 patients
underwent repair of massive rotator cuff tears via the fixa-
tion post technique. The mean age of the patients at the time
of surgery was 68 years (range, 47-89 years), and there
were 14 women and 16 men. Of the patients, 17 were
retired, and 5 of the remaining 13 individuals were still
employed in manual jobs. Twenty-five repairs were per-
formed in the dominant limb. All patients had a clinically
significant rotator cuff tear (minimum diameter of 5 cm) that
was noted arthroscopically and confirmed at open repair.
Most patients presented after an acute exacerbation of a
chronically painful shoulder with limited movement. All had
received a minimum of 3 months’ nonoperative manage-
ment. Three patients had an acute presentation after trauma
to an otherwise normal shoulder proceeding to immediate
From Modbury Public Hospital.
Reprint requests: Robert N. Atkinson, MA, DCH, FRACS(Orth), 135
Hutt St, Adelaide, South Australia 5000 (E-mail: wattle135@
ozemail.com.au).
Copyright © 2006 by Journal of Shoulder and Elbow Surgery
Board of Trustees.
1058-2746/2006/$32.00
doi:10.1016/j.jse.2005.06.005
183