Arch Virol (1991) 119:83-93
_Archives
Vi rology
© Springer-Verlag 1991
Printed in Austria
The use of serological differentiation indices for the phylogenetic analysis
of plant virus relationships
E. P. Rybicki
Department of Microbiology, University of Cape Town, Rondebosch,
Republic of South Africa
Accepted November 29, 1990
Summary. The potential use of serological differentiation indices (SDIs) in the
phylogenetic analysis of plant virus coat protein relationships is presented.
Relationship dendrograms were constructed from SDI data for viruses in the
tymovirus and Subgroup I geminivirus taxonomic groups, using distance or
phenetic methods embodied in the computer programmes Fn'cH and NJa'REE.
Relationship dendrograms for geminiviruses agreed well with those constructed
by others from sequence or other data; the dendrogram for tymoviruses was
not in agreement with one calculated from amino acid composition data, or
from other properties, but appears consistent with recently-shown sequence
similarities between tymoviruses. Implications of these results for the classifi-
cation and taxonomy of plant viruses are discussed.
Introduction
Some of the first quantitative estimates of "difference" between plant viruses
were based on serological data, and serology has long been used for basic
grouping of plant viruses [8, 27]. However, the concept of quantitating these
serological differences is more recent: van Regenmortel and von Wechmar
introduced the concept of the serological differentiation index, or SDI, only in
1970. This is the serological cross-reactivity between two viruses expressed as
the number of twofold dilution steps separating homologous and heterologous
titres. Formerly such values were determined using precipitin techniques; re-
cently, however, ELISA techniques have also been used, and proved to be
perhaps more accurate for such determinations, and certainly capable of dem-
onstrating a wider range of relationships. Jaegle and van Regenmortel [12J
demonstrated the general use of the technique, and Dekker et al. [2J and Pinner
and Markham [ 18, 19-]have used it for determining relationships among isolates
of maize streak virus (MSV) and other related Subgroup I geminiviruses of