Abstract— Knee-ankle-foot orthoses (KAFOs) are full leg
braces for individuals with knee extensor weakness, designed to
support the person during weight bearing activities by
preventing knee flexion. KAFOs typically result in an
unnatural gait pattern and are primarily used for level ground
walking. A novel variable resistance orthotic knee joint, the
Ottawalk-Variable Speed (OWVS), was designed to address
these limitations. This paper presents a pilot test to evaluate the
OWVS functional performance during walking and stair
descent. A carbon-fiber KAFO was adjusted for an able-bodied
participant by a certified orthotist, with a standard orthotic
single axis knee joint on the medial side and the OWVS on the
lateral side. The participant performed level ground walking
(stance-control, open, closed) and stair descent tests. The
operator was able to manually switch between closed mode in
terminal swing to open mode in terminal stance for stance-
control walking. Knee angle kinematics were similar between
open and stance control modes. For stair descent, resistance
settings supported the participant as they lowered their body to
the next step, but with smaller range of motion compared to the
open setting. The Ottawalk-Variable Speed design successfully
controls knee flexion during stance and stair descent, with one
lateral control joint. Mode switching was fast and appropriate.
This microprocessor controlled SCKAFO has a low profile that
fits beneath clothing and the variable resistance design will
allow people to negotiate different terrain types.
I. INTRODUCTION
If the knee extensor muscles are not sufficiently strong,
the knee will collapse due to the external knee flexion
moment [1], [2]. Muscular weakness can result from
peripheral neurological diseases, muscular diseases, central
neurological diseases, spinal cord injury, osteoarthritis, or
severe injury [2]–[6]. Consequences can range from
abnormal gait patterns to complete instability [3], [7]. Even if
the extensor muscles are only slightly weakened, walking
with an abnormal gait pattern is highly energy-consuming
and can cause soft tissue damage [2].
Knee-ankle-foot orthoses (KAFO) are full leg braces
designed for individuals with knee extensor weakness.
Conventional KAFO designs can lock the knee in an
extended position, which keeps the individual stable
throughout stance. However, the resulting stiff-legged gait is
This research was partially funded by the Natural Sciences and
Engineering Research Council of Canada (NSERC). Elan valve supplied by
The Blatchford Group.
Andrew Herbert-Copley is with The Ottawa Hospital Research Institute,
Centre for Rehabilitation Research and Development, Ottawa, ON, K1H
8M2, Canada (e-mail: aherbert@ohri.ca).
Edward D. Lemaire is with The Ottawa Hospital Research Institute,
Centre for Rehabilitation Research and Development, Ottawa, ON, K1H
8M2, Canada; and the Faculty of Medicine, University of Ottawa, Ottawa,
ON, K1H 8M5 (e-mail: elemaire@toh.ca).
Natalie Baddour is with the Department of Mechanical Engineering,
University of Ottawa, Ottawa, ON, K1N 6N5, Canada, (e-mail:
nbaddour@uottawa.ca).
an unnatural and inefficient gait pattern that can lead to soft
tissue injury [2], [7], [8]. Stance control KAFO (SCKAFO)
support the leg during weight bearing and permit free knee
motion during swing. If the user has sufficient hip muscle
strength for forward progression, SCKAFO improve mobility
compared to fixed knee KAFO and provide many clinical
benefits [7]. SCKAFOs on the market use mechanical or
microprocessor control. Mechanical devices have the
advantage of not requiring external power and are generally
smaller, more aesthetically pleasing, and less expensive.
Microprocessor controlled SCKAFOs are the most
functionally advanced, have more reliable mode switching,
and can have multiple settings for different terrain types.
Many SCKAFO devices require a fully extended knee to
engage and disengage the locking mechanism, which may not
be possible for all individuals with knee extensor weakness.
For people who lack strength and/or control to fully extend
their knee consistently, the orthosis will not catch them after
stumbles that land on a flexed knee.
To address these difficulties, a variable resistance orthotic
knee joint was designed, based on the Ottawalk-Speed
(OWS) [9] and a variable flow hydraulic valve adapted from
the Elan prosthetic ankle (Blatchford Group, Basingstoke,
UK). The new knee joint, known as the Ottawalk-Variable
Speed (OWVS), was designed to provide variable knee
flexion resistance to improve mobility on multiple surfaces
and in daily activities.
This paper presents a pilot test to evaluate the OWVS
functional performance during walking and stair descent.
II. METHODS
A. Ottawalk-Variable Speed (OWVS)
The OWVS design (Fig. 1) uses a linear hydraulic
cylinder to guide knee joint motion. A variable flow
hydraulic valve (modified from Elan prosthetic ankle)
controls hydraulic flow from the cylinder and can be
adjusted to change knee joint flexion resistance. The new
orthotic knee joint will allow individuals with knee extensor
weakness to safely walk on level ground with a more natural
gait pattern, descend stairs smoothly, and sit in a controlled
manner. This low profile design will fit beneath normal
clothing, unlike other orthotic options in the same class.
The OWVS has 11 custom settings: open (no resistance
to knee joint flexion); closed (inhibit knee joint flexion); and
9 additional resistance settings designed to support and
smoothly lower users of different weights during stair
descents or stand-to-sit motions. A key design feature is
uninhibited knee joint extension at any setting, so the user
can extend his or her leg to recover from a stumble.
Evaluation of a Variable Resistance Orthotic Knee Joint
Andrew Herbert-Copley, Edward D. Lemaire, and Natalie Baddour
978-1-4577-0220-4/16/$31.00 ©2016 IEEE 2210