Treatment of Seasonal Affective
Disorder: Unipolar Versus
Bipolar Differences
Chang-Ho Sohn, MD and Raymond W. Lam, MD, FRCPC*
Address
* D epar tment of Psychiatr y, U niversity of British C olumbia,
2255 W esbrook Mall, Vancouver, BC , Canada V6T 2A1.
E-mail: r.lam@ ubc.ca
Current Psychiatry Reports 2004, 6: 478–485
Current Science Inc. ISSN 1523-3812
Copyright © 2004 by Current Science Inc.
Introduction
All living organisms are influenced by the seasons and it
is not surprising that there are seasonal changes in
mood and behavior in humans. At the extreme end of
seasonality is seasonal affective disorder (SAD), a sub-
type of mood disorder characterized by regularly occur-
ring depressive episodes, usually in the fall and winter,
with full remission of symptoms in the spring and sum-
mer. In the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual IV (DSM-
IV), SAD is defined as “seasonal pattern specifier” that
can be applied to major depressive disorder or to bipo-
lar disorder. Although the diagnostic criteria for SAD
focus on the seasonal pattern (onset and offset) of
depressive episodes, many patients with SAD experience
atypical vegetative symptoms such as increased sleep
and appetite, carbohydrate craving, and weight gain. The
other prominent feature of SAD is the good response to
bright light therapy.
According to DSM-III R or DSM-IV diagnostic criteria,
the prevalence of SAD has been estimated as 0.5% to 3% in
North American studies [1,2]. In longitudinal follow-up
studies, the diagnosis of SAD shows similar stability as that
of other depressive subtypes, with approximately 30% of
patients with continuing with a recurrent seasonal depres-
sive pattern, approximately 20% in clinical remission, and
the remaining 50% experiencing more complex depressive
patterns [3,4].
This paper reviews the pathophysiology and biological
treatment of SAD, focusing on pharmacotherapy and light
therapy, with specific clinical considerations when treating
patients with bipolar disorder with a seasonal pattern
(bipolar SAD).
Patho physio lo gy o f Seaso nal
Affective Disorder
The pathogenesis and pathophysiology of SAD is uncer-
tain, although there are several major hypotheses (for
review, see [5•]). Initially, there was a focus on chronobi-
ological theories that considered symptoms of SAD to be
analogous to seasonal behavioral patterns in animals that
were dependent on the light-dark cycle (photoperiod). In
addition, the effects of bright light are known to affect cir-
cadian rhythms in humans through the circadian pace-
maker located in the suprachiasmatic nucleus of the
hypothalamus. For example, the photoperiod hypothesis
of SAD attributed its cause to the shorter winter photope-
riod [6]. Other researchers proposed that SAD resulted
from phase delayed internal circadian rhythms relative to
other rhythms like the sleep-wake cycle [7,8]. Properly
timed bright light would correct these phase-delayed cir-
cadian rhythms [9]. However, other studies report con-
flicting findings that are inconsistent with
chronobiological theories [10].
There also is considerable evidence supporting major
roles for monoamine neurotransmitter systems in the
pathophysiology of SAD. In particular, there are consis-
tent findings of serotonergic dysfunction in SAD. Given
the role of hypothalamic serotonin in satiety and feeding
and sleep regulation, serotonergic disturbances may
partly explain the carbohydrate craving, weight gain, and
Evidence-based treatments for seasonal affective disorder
(SAD ) include light therapy and pharmacotherapy. W e
briefly review the diagnosis and treatment of SAD, focusing
on clinical and treatment differences between patients with
unipolar and bipolar illness. Special considerations for the
management of SAD in patients with bipolar disorder are
discussed, including the need to monitor for emergence of
manic and hypomanic mood switches, to use mood stabiliz-
ers in patients with bipolar I disorder, and to be aware of
potential interactions between bright light and medications
used in treating bipolar disorder. Chronobiological treat-
ments such as bright light therapy may be combined with
pharmacotherapy to enhance therapeutic effects, reduce
adverse side effects, and optimize treatment in patients
with seasonal and nonseasonal bipolar disorder.