Communication with Stakeholders:
An Integrated Approach
Eileen Scholes and David Clutterbuck
TODAY, THE QUESTION FOR THE Board and for those
who advise them in the area of strategy and com-
munication planning, is not whether they should be
communicating with this or that stakeholder group
but how to manage communication across stake-
holder groups.
Academics and commentators may still be arguing
about what constitutes a stakeholder. Or whether it is
best (or indeed feasible) to take a "stakeholder
approach", or only a "shareholder return", approach
to business (Andrew Campbell and John Argenti's
recent exchange in Vol 30 of Long Range Planning
illustrates graphically this divergence of views).
On the front-line, managers are confronting the
need to deal with the growing power of individual
stakeholder groups and the increasingly complex
links between them, often with mixed success. In the
search for possible redeeming strategies, it is impor-
tant that we first revisit the factors that lie behind the
power and the links.
• Globalisation. More organisations are fighting their
battles on a world-wide stage--not only for custom
but for capital, for employees with the right skills
and attitudes and even for their licence to operate
in local communities. At the same time, industries
which are being forced to consolidate inter-
nationally (even Defence, for example) are seeing
the distinction between competitor, customer and
supplier become blurred, making each player more
influential on the other.
• The rise of the professional investor. The overall
proportion of funds in private hands has declined
dramatically: fund managers' interests in how the
company is and will be performing goes way deeper
than the annual P&L statement, nor will they wait
for the annual meeting to make their views heard.
• The rise of the sophisticated customer. On every
aspect of the "value" mix--from price and product
to convenience and service, today's customer is
increasingly aware of new possibilities and there-
fore more demanding, a trend only intensified by
the consolidation of consumer product and retail
chain branding.
• The rise of the empowered employee. With old
managerial structures being dismantled and a
reduction in the power of trade unions, individuals
are taking more responsibility for improved per-
formance--their own and the organisation'swand
in turn, demanding more of a say in what happens
around them.
• The information revolution. Inside and outside
organisations, the number of people who may now
see, hear and start reacting within minutes to news
of a take-over, a strike or a chemical spill, for exam-
ple, is increasing at a phenomenal rate, thanks to
the spread of electronic communication.
• Rising awareness of the influence of business on
society (for good and ill). Ethics and corporate
Pergamon
PII: S0024-6301(98)00007-7
LongRangePlanning, Vol. 31, No. 2, pp. 227 to 238, 1998
© 1998 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved
Printed in Great Britain
0024-6301/98 $19.00+0.00