Nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopic
analysis of ethyl ester yield in the
transesterification of vegetable oil: an accurate
method for a truly quantitative analysis
Giovanni Pimenta Mambrini,
a
Caue Ribeiro
a
* and Luiz Alberto Colnago
a
Biodiesel has recently gained importance as an alternative to fossil diesel. However, the development of more efficient
biodiesel formation processes still depends on the use of fast and accurate analytical techniques to evaluate the conversion
degree of the transesterification reaction. Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy has been used for this purpose,
but some experimental details still need to be addressed. Therefore, in this communication, the experimental conditions
for a truly quantitative NMR analysis of biodiesel formation are presented. The longitudinal relaxation time (T
1
), which is
the determining factor for quantitative analysis, was measured using an inversion-recovery method, and a maximum value
of 2.35 s was obtained for a biodiesel sample. A linear determination coefficient of r
2
= 0.99 was obtained when a time delay
between pulses longer than 5T
1
=15 s was used, whereas strong deviations were observed when using shorter delays.
Copyright © 2012 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Keywords:
1
H-NMR; biodiesel; transesterification; quantification; relaxation time
Introduction
Recently, much research investigating new energy sources has
been conducted. Agriculturally derived fuels (biofuels) have
attracted significant attention because they are derived from
renewable sources, are biodegradable, have low toxicity, and
have a low-pollution potential relative to their fossil-based
counterparts.
[1]
The conversion of vegetable oils and fats into
biodiesel therefore, is one of the most studied options for diesel
replacement.
[2]
Particularly in Brazil, the various sources of natural
oils and previous success in sugarcane ethanol production
[3]
provide strong motivation for the further development of
different alternatives.
However, the processes for biodiesel production are still a
challenge in terms of productivity and cost, and significant efforts
are necessary to attain a self-sustainable system for biodiesel
production.
[4,5]
These efforts include discovering new catalysts
and consolidating production processes. Naturally, these tasks
depend on a reliable, efficient, and fast method for quantitative
measurement of the conversion to biodiesel. In the literature,
methods such as gas
[6]
or size-exclusion chromatography
[7]
have
been proposed, but they are slow analytical methods.
To the best of our knowledge, NMR-based methods are one of
the best choices for fast and reliable measurement. For example,
Ghesti et al.
[3]
proposed an NMR method that is based on the
measurement of the relative areas of the peaks associated with
the glycerol and ethoxyl groups in a mixture of oil and biodiesel.
Additionally, Jin et al.
[8]
studied methyl ester formation using
NMR spectroscopy, demonstrating that this technique allows
the detection of diglycerides and monoglycerides in the reaction
medium in addition to the starting oil and the product. The
literature also contains research about the quantification of the
oil content in seeds based on this technique, which keeps the
seed intact after analysis.
[9,10]
Finally, Nagy et al.
[11]
used
31
P NMR to verify the biodiesel preparation process. These
examples show how NMR can be useful for biodiesel research.
Experimental conditions can strongly interfere with the NMR
signal, thus impeding a truly quantitative measurement. Usually,
the extent of transesterification is measured by integrating the area
under the peaks corresponding to the biodiesel and oil. For
quantitative NMR analysis, it is necessary to know the values of
the longitudinal relaxation time, T
1
, such that a time interval
between pulses (T
p
) longer than 5T
1
can be used to allow the spins
to return to their fundamental state.
[12]
It must be emphasized that
very few papers describe the NMR parameters used in biodiesel
conversion, and the routine adopted is often not adequate
because it is simply an adaptation of other quantification protocols
that were not developed for this specific purpose.
[13]
Therefore, in this paper, we discuss the importance of
various NMR variables in a quantitative measurement of
biodiesel in oil mixtures, focusing on the importance of an
adequate choice of T
p
. The results show that significant deviations
from linearity can appear due to an erroneous choice in this
single parameter. Therefore, using a correct procedure with an
adequate T
p
value can provide results that agree well with
expected values, demonstrating the potential of NMR techniques
for biodiesel analysis.
* Correspondence to: Caue Ribeiro, Embrapa Instrumentação, Rua XV de Novembro
1452, São Carlos, SP, Brazil, CEP 13560–970. E-mail: caue@cnpdia.embrapa.br
a Embrapa Instrumentação, Rua XV de Novembro 1452, São Carlos, SP, Brazil,
CEP 13560-970
Magn. Reson. Chem. 2012, 50,1–4 Copyright © 2012 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Rapid Communication
Received: 8 February 2011 Revised: 2 September 2011 Accepted: 8 September 2011 Published online in Wiley Online Library: 5 February 2012
(wileyonlinelibrary.com) DOI 10.1002/mrc.2831
1