Oncology
Bladder Neck Contractures Related to the
Use of Hem-O-Lok Clips in Robot-Assisted
Laparoscopic Radical Prostatectomy
Kevin B. Blumenthal, Douglas E. Sutherland, Kristofer R. Wagner, Harold A. Frazier,
and Jason D. Engel
OBJECTIVE Recently, several large series of robot-assisted laparoscopic radical prostatectomy (RALP) have
described a low incidence of bladder neck contractures (BNC). We have had a similar experience
at our institution. Our objective is to describe our experience with BNC after RALP and a novel
relationship to the use of Hem-o-lok Clips (HOLC).
METHODS We reviewed a database of patients who underwent RALP at our institution from January 2004
to September 2007 and identified patients with BNC or complications related to the use of
HOLC. We performed a retrospective chart review to attempt to determine the cause of each
BNC. We also performed a PubMed search and review of the Food and Drug Administration
Manufacturer and User Facility Device Experience (MAUDE) database.
RESULTS Of 524 patients undergoing RALP, 4 had a BNC develop, 2 of the BNCs were associated with
HOLC migration and erosion into the vesicourethral anastomosis, and 1 was found to have
HOLC migration within the bladder. A fifth patient had an anastomotic leak develop secondary
to a HOLC that migrated into the bladder neck. Two similar cases of HOLC-related migration
have been reported to MAUDE.
CONCLUSIONS When early BNC or unexplained urinary retention occurs after RALP, one should have a high
index of suspicion for migration of HOLC. Clip use should be minimized on tissue immediately
adjacent to the anastomosis, and every effort should be made to retrieve loose clips after the
procedure. UROLOGY 72: 158 –161, 2008. © 2008 Elsevier Inc.
B
ladder neck contracture (BNC) is a complication
of prostate surgery that can be a devastating prob-
lem leading to urinary retention, incontinence,
and multiple repeated invasive procedures. The esti-
mated incidence after open radical prostatectomy ranges
from 3% to 26%.
1–9
Risk factors may include previous
surgery, radiation, postoperative bleeding, or anastomotic
leakage. Robot-assisted laparoscopic radical prostatec-
tomy (RALP) is becoming a more prevalent procedure
with clear differences in postoperative complications
when compared with open retropubic radical prostatec-
tomy (RRP). Several RALP series have suggested that
the incidence of BNC after RALP may be lower than in
patients undergoing RRP, ranging from 0.6% to 3% after
RALP.
10 –15
The cause of this lower incidence is unclear.
The purpose of this study was to evaluate our own expe-
rience with post-RALP BNC, and document the rela-
tionship of BNC formation with the use of Hem-o-lok
clips (HOLC; Teleflex Medical, Research Triangle Park,
NC).
MATERIAL AND METHODS
The robotic program at our institution was initiated in January
2004. We have since maintained a prospective database of
clinical, surgical, and pathologic parameters. For this study, we
retrospectively reviewed our database of complications to iden-
tify all patients who had a BNC develop. We also performed a
search of the United States Food and Drug Administration
Manufacturer and User Facility Device Experience Database
(MAUDE) to identify reported failures of HOLC between July
2005 and June 2007.
We perform the vesicourethral anastomosis after RALP by
using the double-arm technique described by Van Velthoven et
al.
16
Two monocryl sutures, tied together at their ends, are used
to perform a running closure. One arm is started at the 5:30
position and is run counter clockwise to the 12:00-o’clock
position, and the second arm is started at the 6:30 position and
run clockwise to the 12:00-o’clock position. The 2 arms are tied
together at the 12:00-o’clock position with the knot in an
extravesical location.
Originally, we ligated the vasa and seminal vesicle arteries
along with the prostatic pedicles after placing large HOLC to
From the Department of Urology, the George Washington University Hospital, Wash-
ington District of Columbia; the Division of Urology, Scott and White Health System,
the Texas A&M Health Science Center College of Medicine, Temple Texas.
Reprint requests: Douglas E. Sutherland, M.D., George Washington University
Hospital, Department of Urology, 2150 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW 3rd Floor, Wash-
ington, DC 20037. E-mail: desutherland@gmail.com
Submitted: September 7, 2007, accepted (with revisions): November 19, 2007.
158 © 2008 Elsevier Inc. 0090-4295/08/$34.00
All Rights Reserved doi:10.1016/j.urology.2007.11.105