Aldehydes as alkyl carbanion equivalents for
additions to carbonyl compounds
Haining Wang
†
, Xi-Jie Dai
†
and Chao-Jun Li
*
Nucleophilic addition reactions of organometallic reagents to carbonyl compounds for carbon–carbon bond construction
have played a pivotal role in modern chemistry. However, this reaction’s reliance on petroleum-derived chemical
feedstocks and a stoichiometric quantity of metal have prompted the development of many carbanion equivalents and
catalytic metal alternatives. Here, we show that naturally occurring carbonyls can be used as latent alkyl carbanion
equivalents for additions to carbonyl compounds, via reductive polarity reversal. Such ‘umpolung’ reactivity is facilitated by
a ruthenium catalyst and diphosphine ligand under mild conditions, delivering synthetically valuable secondary and
tertiary alcohols in up to 98% yield. The unique chemoselectivity exhibited by carbonyl-derived carbanion equivalents is
demonstrated by their tolerance to protic reaction media and good functional group compatibility. Enantioenriched tertiary
alcohols can also be accessed with the aid of chiral ligands, albeit with moderate stereocontrol. Such carbonyl-derived
carbanion equivalents are anticipated to find broad utility in chemical bond formation.
T
he nucleophilic addition of organometallic reagents to carbo-
nyl compounds, to form new carbon–carbon bonds, is a funda-
mental process in contemporary organic synthesis
1–3
. This simple
alkylation process, complementary to the reduction of carbonyl com-
pounds, provides a reliable method for generating a wide array of
alcohol products. These alcohols are frequently encountered as key
building blocks in the synthesis of complex pharmaceutical drugs and
biologically active molecules. The discovery of Grignard reagents as car-
banion equivalents
4
and their subsequent additions to carbonyl com-
pounds marked a milestone in synthetic chemistry, enabling facile
access to a diverse range of alcohols using preformed organomagnesium
reagents with high generality, reactivity and easy manipulation
5–8
. Since
then, other organometallic reagents
9
, such as those based on zinc
10
, alu-
minium
11
, copper
12
and titanium
13
, have been sought and used to
achieve better selectivity. However, the preparation of these robust orga-
nometallic reagents requires stoichiometric quantities of metal (Fig. 1a).
Despite considerable advances, and the abundance of organo-
metallic reagents developed for additions to carbonyl compounds,
three key challenges have endured. First, the dependence on
stoichiometric, pre-formed organometallic reagents in carbonyl
addition reactions produces copious metal waste. This is particularly
problematic for large-scale synthesis, as it complicates synthetic
operations and raises environmental concerns. In addition,
petroleum-derived chemical feedstocks (that is, organic halides) are
typically used to prepare organometallic reagents. Their paucity in
nature
14
constrains the types of nucleophiles accessible to perform
carbonyl addition reactions without prior functionalization.
Furthermore, the high nucleophilicity and basicity of most organo-
metallic reagents generally result in poor selectivity, making these
reagents inferior candidates in late-stage chemical transformations
where highly functionalized molecules are present.
To address these challenges, much effort has been devoted to
developing original catalytic and asymmetric methods to produce
enantioenriched alcohols, whereby π-unsaturated hydrocarbons
(alkenes or alkynes) are masked as carbanion equivalents
(Fig. 1b). Krische and co-workers have pioneered stereoselective
coupling reactions between diverse π-unsaturated reactants and
aldehydes under hydrogenative conditions catalysed by late
transition metals
15,16
. Hoveyda and colleagues have successfully
developed copper-catalysed borylative enantioselective additions
to carbonyl compounds using olefin-derived nucleophiles
17,18
.
Montgomery, Jamison and co-workers have designed nickel-based
catalysts for stereoselective aldehyde additions, in which alkynes are
employed as carbanion equivalents
19–21
. To synthesize more sterically
encumbered tertiary alcohols, Buchwald, Liu and colleagues have
devised enantioenriched alkyl copper intermediates, synthesized
from olefins, for additions to ketones
22
. The catalytic generation of
carbanion equivalents from either alkenes or alkynes, elegantly exem-
plified in these reports, has successfully addressed some of the long-
standing challenges facing organometallic reagents. Nevertheless, as
the chemical industry shifts from using petrochemicals to renewable
feedstocks, the synthetic community is increasingly giving attention
to more sustainable and efficient chemical syntheses
23,24
.
In this context, the development of carbanion equivalents that
originate from naturally occurring chemical feedstocks, require
only a catalytic quantity of metal, have improved compatibility
towards benign protic solvents and various functional groups,
and generate innocuous by-products would be highly desirable
for additions to carbonyl compounds. Here, we report such alkyl
carbanion equivalents, derived from the naturally prevalent carbo-
nyls with umpolung reactivity
25–29
, for carbonyl addition reactions
(Fig. 1c). Very recently, we have pioneered a ruthenium-catalysed
redox system
30
for direct primary alcohol deoxygenation
31
.
This practical deoxygenation chemistry evolved from our initial
iridium-based system
32
and proved to be highly chemo- and regio-
selective in complex molecules such as alkaloids and steroids. The
proposed mechanism involves the in situ generation of a ruthe-
nium-coordinated hydrazone intermediate A, followed by a ruthe-
nium-assisted Wolff–Kishner (WK) reduction under relatively
low-temperature conditions (Fig. 2a). Intriguingly, when benzylic
alcohols were subjected to the same catalytic reaction conditions,
a trace amount of reductive C-C coupling product—the carbonyl
addition product—was observed. On the basis of this serendipitous
discovery, we hypothesized that the coordinately unsaturated ruthe-
nium complex in A might rapidly metallate another carbonyl com-
pound and subsequently rearrange to give intermediate C, via
Department of Chemistry and FQRNT Centre for Green Chemistry and Catalysis, McGill University, 801 Sherbrooke Street West, Montreal, Quebec H3A
0B8, Canada.
†
These authors contributed equally to this work. *e-mail: cj.li@mcgill.ca
ARTICLES
PUBLISHED ONLINE: 5 DECEMBER 2016 | DOI: 10.1038/NCHEM.2677
NATURE CHEMISTRY | ADVANCE ONLINE PUBLICATION | www.nature.com/naturechemistry 1
© 2016 Macmillan Publishers Limited, part of Springer Nature. All rights reserved.