1005 SACRIFICE AND HOLY WAR
CHAPTER II-6-1.4
Sacrifice and Holy War: A Study of
Religion and Violence
VOLKHARD KRECH
I. THE SIGNIFICANCE OF VIOLENCE IN
COMPARATIVE RELIGIOUS STUDIES
Religions are a part of the cultural interpretation of primary experience and as such are
intimately bound up with the elementary conditions and driving forces of human life.
Depending on their orientation, religions can channel, sublimate, or arouse both vital and
destructive forces. Religions deal with the forces of nature and attempt to interpret them;
they are also able both to avert and to unleash psychological driving forces and conflicts
of interest in society. Religions are able to do this because they are symbolic systems
behind the binding ways through which people understand themselves and the world.
They are prone to generate conflict when they are “an aggregate state of a given culture ...
arming itself to go to its limits” (Assmann, 1992:157). If religions are concerned with “the
whole” and strive for ultimate values and binding ways of understanding themselves and
the world, then particular conditions—be they economic, political, or broadly cultural and
thus not necessarily inherent to the given religion—can often mean that representatives
and adherents of these religions develop a certain fanaticism. However, whether or not
their commitment is expressed violently depends on numerous variables both inherent and
exterior to the actual religion. The history of religions has not been able to establish a
definite correlation—be it positive or negative—between religion and violence. Religion
can give violence content and an object, but it is not its original source. Nor is there suffi-
cient evidence for the opposite correlation. Violence can be unleashed without religion, of
course, and can also be averted without taking recourse to religion. However, what needs
to be explained is the observation that religious convictions are particularly well suited to
incite violence and to make it erupt.
W. Heitmeyer and J. Hagan (eds.), International Handbook of Violence Research, 1005–1021.
© 2003 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
1005
In: Wilhelm Heitmeyer, John Hagan (Hrsg.),
International Handbook of Violence Research.
Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers, 1005–1021.