LETTERS
940 VOLUME 22 | NUMBER 8 | AUGUST 2016 NATURE MEDICINE
Positive expectations contribute to the clinical benefits of the
placebo effect
1,2
. Such positive expectations are mediated
by the brain’s reward system
3,4
; however, it remains unknown
whether and how reward system activation affects the body’s
physiology and, specifically, immunity. Here we show that
activation of the ventral tegmental area (VTA), a key component
of the reward system, strengthens immunological host
defense. We used ‘designer receptors exclusively activated by
designer drugs’ (DREADDs) to directly activate dopaminergic
neurons in the mouse VTA and characterized the subsequent
immune response after exposure to bacteria (Escherichia coli),
using time-of-flight mass cytometry (CyTOF) and functional
assays. We found an increase in innate and adaptive immune
responses that were manifested by enhanced antibacterial
activity of monocytes and macrophages, reduced in vivo
bacterial load and a heightened T cell response in the mouse
model of delayed-type hypersensitivity. By chemically ablating
the sympathetic nervous system (SNS), we showed that the
reward system’s effects on immunity are, at least partly,
mediated by the SNS. Thus, our findings establish a causal
relationship between the activity of the VTA and the immune
response to bacterial infection.
Despite its elusive nature, the potency of the placebo effect is recog-
nized in modern medicine. For 50 years, clinical trials have included
a placebo group to control for nonspecific effects, such as statistical
errors, spontaneous recovery and patient expectations. Such expecta-
tion of clinical improvement has a key role in the placebo effect
5,6
and
has been associated with activation of the brain’s reward system
3,4
.
It is, however, unknown whether and how activity of the brain’s reward
system can affect physical health, specifically immunity, and, if it does,
what peripheral components mediate this interaction.
The immune system responds to psychological and cognitive
factors
7,8
, including positive emotions
9–14
, in which the reward
system has a crucial role
15,16
. Thus, we designed our study to
examine whether reward system activation, which is evident in the
placebo response and in positive expectation, can impact immunity.
To determine the effects of the reward system on immunity, we
focused on dopaminergic neurons in the VTA, a central mediator of
reward-related stimuli and positive expectations
17
.
To manipulate neuronal activity, we used DREADDs, which are
G-protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) that have been mutated to
be activated only by an otherwise inert ligand (clozapine-N-oxide;
CNO)
18
. These DREADDs activate endogenous downstream signal
transduction pathways to augment neuronal activity
18
. To express
DREADDs and a fluorescent reporter marker in VTA dopaminergic
neurons, we stereotactically injected a viral vector that expresses
a Cre-dependent DREADD construct (AAV8-hSyn1-DIO-hM3D(Gq)-
mCherry) under the control of the human synapsin I (Syn1) promoter
in mice that express Cre under the tyrosine hydroxylase (Th) pro-
moter (which we refer to as TH-Cre mice). As a control, we infected
another group of mice with a sham virus that expresses only the fluo-
rescent reporter (Fig. 1a). Throughout the study, mice injected with
the sham virus were used as the control group. Immunohistochemical
analysis revealed that TH
+
cells in the VTA expressed the fluorescent
reporter (Fig. 1b and Supplementary Fig. 1). Among these TH
+
cells,
the efficiency of viral infection was 58% ± 4% (Fig. 1c). We verified
DREADD-induced neuronal activation by analyzing the expression
of c-Fos, an immediate-early activation marker, following intraperi-
toneal (i.p.) injection of CNO. c-Fos expression was evident in 42% ±
0.5% of DREADD-expressing cells, as compared to 3% ± 1% in con-
trol mice infected with the sham virus (Fig. 1d,e). To determine the
behavioral effects of DREADD-induced VTA activation, we evalu-
ated mouse behavior using the ‘conditioned place preference’ (CPP)
paradigm. This assay quantifies an animal’s preference for a location
in which it had a subjectively positive experience
19
. Despite the low
temporal resolution of DREADDs, mice in which VTA activation
was induced (hereafter referred to as VTA-activated mice) showed a
31.5% ± 12.6% increased preference for the chamber in which they
were injected with CNO (Fig. 1f–h). In addition, VTA-activated
mice participated in more social interactions with cage mates
(44.4% ± 12.9% increase; Supplementary Fig. 2), consistent with a
recent report that found VTA activation increases social behavior
20
.
Thus, we concluded that DREADDs were specifically expressed in
VTA TH
+
neurons and that they activated the reward system in the
experimental mice.
Activation of the reward system boosts innate and
adaptive immunity
Tamar L Ben-Shaanan
1,2
, Hilla Azulay-Debby
1,2
, Tania Dubovik
1
, Elina Starosvetsky
1
, Ben Korin
1,2
,
Maya Schiller
1,2
, Nathaniel L Green
1,2
, Yasmin Admon
1
, Fahed Hakim
1,3
, Shai S Shen-Orr
1,4,5
& Asya Rolls
1,2,5
1
Department of Immunology, Rappaport Faculty of Medicine, Technion–Israel Institute of Technology, Haifa, Israel.
2
Center of Science and Engineering of Neuronal
Systems, Rappaport Faculty of Medicine, Technion–Israel Institute of Technology, Haifa, Israel.
3
Pediatric Pulmonary Unit, Rambam Health Care Campus, Haifa, Israel.
4
Faculty of Biology, Technion–Israel Institute of Technology, Haifa, Israel.
5
These authors jointly directed this work. Correspondence should be addressed to A.R.
(rolls@technion.ac.il) or S.S.S.-O. (shenorr@technion.ac.il).
Received 15 January; accepted 1 June; published online 4 July 2016; doi:10.1038/nm.4133
npg
© 2016 Nature America, Inc. All rights reserved.