Wear 269 (2010) 339–343
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Wear
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/wear
Determining the coefficient of friction between solids without sliding
S. Reina
a
, R.J.H. Paynter
b
, D.A. Hills
b
, D. Dini
a,∗
a
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Imperial College London, South Kensington Campus, Exhibition Road, SW7 2AZ London, United Kingdom
b
Department of Engineering Science, University of Oxford, Parks Road, OX1 3PJ Oxford, United Kingdom
article info
Article history:
Received 22 May 2009
Received in revised form 23 March 2010
Accepted 15 April 2010
Available online 2 May 2010
Keywords:
Friction
Partial Slip
Sliding
Quadratic Programming
Fretting Test
abstract
A novel method for measuring the interfacial coefficient of friction between two solids which avoids
sliding is described, and sample results are given. The technique makes use of the fact that a carefully
controlled sequence of partial slip states between contacting bodies may be used to produce relative
motion whose extent is a strong function of the coefficient of friction. It is argued that this approach
induces much less surface damage in the components, and therefore yields a value for the coefficient of
friction which is much more representative of their unmodified condition.
© 2010 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
It is truism in physics that quantities cannot be measured with-
out changing them; a voltmeter draws current; the insertion of a
load cell in a load path introduces compliance, and so forth. Sim-
ilarly, the coefficient of friction is normally measured by sliding
solids pressed together, and the process of sliding normally causes
significant surface modification, and hence a change in the coef-
ficient of friction. It could be argued that conducting tests under
an even lower normal force, and extrapolating back to zero would
circumvent the problem, but this presumes that the coefficient of
friction is truly load independent, and it may be desirable to mea-
sure its value at representative contact pressures. One situation
where a really detailed knowledge of the value of the coefficient of
friction is important, and sliding in the prototype is absent, is the
stationary contact suffering partial slip, or fretting. It may seem a
contradiction in terms to measure the coefficient of friction with-
out sliding the bodies, but this is not so, and a careful exploitation
of the phenomenon of partial slip may reveal the value of the coef-
ficient of friction. One attempt at this has already been made by
Pasanen et al. [1], who used visible evidence of surface damage
caused by slip to measure the extent of the slip annulus in a Cat-
taneo [5] type experiment. Previous attempts to infer the friction
from the hysteretic response of contact pairs subjected to partial
slip include the work by Fouvry and co-workers (see e.g. [2]). Other
∗
Corresponding Author. Tel.: +44 0 2075947242; fax: +44 0 2075947023.
E-mail address: d.dini@imperial.ac.uk (D. Dini).
authors have developed techniques for estimating the slip zone fric-
tion coefficient from a measured mean value for different contact
configurations [3,4].
In this paper completely different quantitative evidence is used
to deduce the coefficient of friction. The experiment utilises the
same apparatus employed at Oxford and elsewhere to investigate
fretting fatigue, but it might, potentially, be executed with a sim-
pler single actuator machine, as will become clear. Fig. 1 shows an
idealisation of the apparatus, and its key features. The basic idea is
to induce a cyclic set of loads which alternately inject a slip region
into one end of the contact and abstract it at the other, so that, after
each cycle of loading, there is, potentially, a net rigid body move-
ment of the indenter. In many respects the idea was foreshadowed
by Dundurs and Comninou [6] in a paper where they describe drag-
ging a rug over the floor by injecting a ‘ruche’ or dislocation at one
end which may emerge at the other. Although, in principle, a wide
range of different loading histories might be exploited, to reduce
the number of possibilities which might be investigated the fol-
lowing was chosen: first, the indenter is pressed into contact by a
normal force, P, so as to produce contact over a strip of half-width a,
and where the contact pressure distribution, p(x), taken as positive
when compressive, is given explicitly by the usual Hertz formula:
p(x) =-p
o
1 - (x/a)
2
where p
o
=
2P
a
. (1)
A shear force, Q, insufficient to cause sliding, is then applied and
held constant. A bulk tension, , is now developed, and it is assumed
that this varies cyclically between limits
max
and
min
where, for
reasons of ensuring stability of the specimen, we would prefer the
latter to be positive. The question we now ask is whether there is
0043-1648/$ – see front matter © 2010 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.wear.2010.04.017