© 2008 The Author
Journal Compilation © 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd
Religion Compass 3/1 (2009): 58–71, 10.1111/j.1749-8171.2008.00125.x
Disputes over Yasukuni Shrine and Its War
Dead in Contemporary Japan
Michiaki Okuyama*
Nanzan University
Abstract
Yasukuni Shrine, a Shinto sanctuary located in Tokyo, has become the focus of
a recent dispute in Japan, and a source of criticism against Japanese politicians
by neighboring Asian countries. Especially since the former Prime Minister
Koizumi Jun’ichiró visited Yasukuni once every year during the period of his
administration (2001–2006), arguments have been accumulated both in Japan and
abroad. This essay tries to review some of the arguments over the war dead
and war memory in modern Japanese history, referring also to more specific
issues such as the Class A war criminals and Li Ying’s documentary film Yasukuni
(2007).
Former Japanese Prime Minister Koizumi Jun’ichiró, who was in office
from 2001 to 2006, is known for his uncompromising stance in patronizing
Yasukuni Shrine. Once every year Koizumi visited Yasukuni as Prime
Minister, an action that, on one hand, caused harsh criticism among
Chinese, Koreans, and also some Japanese, but on the other hand stimulated
the growth of nationalism and patriotism not only among conservative
Japanese but others as well. This situation has brought into relief the
polarization of opinions among Japanese people over their country’s modern
history in general, and over the war dead that resulted from Japanese
military aggression in Asia and the Pacific regions in particular.
During the Koizumi administration, both journalistic and academic
discussions were conducted in Japan over Yasukuni Shrine and the war dead
in the context of history, sociology, religious studies, and international
relations. In reviewing some of these discussions, I find there emerge
differing ramifications according to the interests of each advocate. At the
most concrete level, there has developed scholarly and journalistic research
that delves into the history of Yasukuni Shrine itself and the surrounding
political issues before and after World War II. These enquiries have been
clarifying Yasukuni Shrine’s multifaceted history until today.
1
On the issue
of the war dead, Japanese people should have developed their own methods
of commemoration once they were freed from the national monopoly of
them until the end of war. If we solely focus on Yasukuni Shrine, we may