European Journal of Economics, Finance and Administrative Sciences
ISSN 1450-2275 Issue 35 (2011)
© EuroJournals, Inc. 2011
http://www.eurojournals.com
Does Corporate Governance Constrain Earnings Management?
Evidence from U.S. Firms
Mondher Kouki
Faculty of Economic Sciences and Management of Tunis
E-mail: koukimondher@yahoo.fr
Abderrazek Elkhaldi
Faculty of Law and Economic and Political Sciences of Sousse
E-mail: Abderrazek.elkhaldi@yahoo.fr
Hanen Atri
Higher School of Economics and Business of Tunis
E-mail: hanenatrifinance@yahoo.fr
Slim Souid
Faculty of Law and Economic and Political Sciences of Sousse
E-mail: souidslim@yahoo.fr
Abstract
The purpose of this paper is to examine the influence of corporate governance mechanisms
on earnings management for a panel of 171 U.S firms from 1998 to 2005. Consistent with
earlier work, we find that auditing committee independency, the separation between
chairman and CEO and manager as a membership to nominating committee are the most
significant constraints to earnings management. These results recommend us to deduce that
Governance instruments affect earnings management decision and control efficiency
depends on: (1) Board size that should be neither too large nor too small in order to avoid
diverting opinions that profit the manager and allow earnings management. (2) Auditing
committee independency is necessary to deal with manager’s opportunistic behavior and
earnings manipulation. (3) A separation function, which means that manager should not be
at the same time Chairman, is also necessary to have an optimal governance system and to
avoid earnings management. (4) Nominating committee independency and non manager
membership are required to succeed corporate governance mechanisms.
Keywords: Earnings management, CEO, Board of directors, auditing committee,
nominating committee, and ownership structure.
1. Introduction
The last few years witnessed a series of accounting and financial scandals
1
leading investors to
discredit financial information. In fact, sudden firms’ bankruptcies led investors to devote more interest
1
Enron, WorldCom, Xerox…