PII S0736-4679(02)00438-9
Clinical
Communications
HYPOTHERMIA FROM PROLONGED IMMERSION: BIOPHYSICAL PARAMETERS
OF A SURVIVOR
Thomas J. Nuckton, MD,* Daniel Goldreich, PhD,† Kenneth D. Rogaski, MS,* Tonia M. Lessani, DO,‡
Paul J. Higgins, MD, USPHS,§ and David M. Claman, MD*
*Division of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine and the Cardiovascular Research Institute, University of California, San Francisco,
California, †The Rangos School of Health Sciences, Duquesne University, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, , ‡Department of Internal
Medicine, Peninsula Hospital, Burlingame, California, and §Office of Health Services, United States Coast Guard Headquarters,
Washington, DC,
Reprint Address: Thomas J. Nuckton, MD, Cardiovascular Research Institute, University of California, San Francisco, 505 Parnassus
Avenue, Box 0130, San Francisco, CA 94143-0130
e Abstract—We report a case of survival following pro-
longed immersion and hypothermia. The patient survived for
over 9 h in open water, after his vessel capsized and sank in the
Pacific Ocean off the coast of Northern California. Water
temperature on the day of the sinking was 14.4°C (58.0°F).
Although he did have adequate flotation, the patient did not
wear a survival suit. On initial physical examination in the
Emergency Department (ED), the patient’s rectal tempera-
ture was 30.0°C (86.0°F). With active rewarming, his temper-
ature returned to normal (37.0°C {98.6°F}) within 5 h. Body
fat of the patient was 19.6%, near the 50th percentile for his
age (19.0%). Surface/volume ratio of the patient (.0228 m
2
/L)
was 19% smaller than a predicted average (.0282 m
2
/L). We
believe that the patient’s large body habitus contributed to
survival and that surface/volume ratio was likely the biophys-
ical variable most closely associated with decreased cooling.
© 2002 Elsevier Science Inc.
e Keywords— hypothermia; immersion; rewarming; re-
suscitation; near-drowning
INTRODUCTION
Survival of prolonged immersion is based on many fac-
tors. Time spent in the water, sea state, water tempera-
ture, and individual behavior all have been related to
cooling rate and to the chance of survival (1– 8). The
relationship between body habitus and immersion cool-
ing rate also has been studied. Body fat has long been
associated with cooling rate, and individuals with greater
amounts of body fat are known to cool more slowly than
leaner counterparts (8 –11). Overall body size, which can
be reflected by surface/volume ratio, is also an important
factor for predicting the rate of cooling (5,7,10 –13).
Despite numerous controlled studies, there are few data
from actual immersion survivors. We report the detailed
biophysical parameters of a patient who survived pro-
longed immersion and hypothermia. We believe that the
patient’s large body habitus, as reflected by these bio-
physical parameters, contributed greatly to his survival.
CASE REPORT
In September 2000, a 50-foot fishing vessel capsized and
sank in the Pacific Ocean off the coast of Northern
California. Water temperature on the day of the sinking
was 14.4°C (58.0°F). Large (approximately 5–7 foot)
RECEIVED: 19 June 2001; FINAL SUBMISSION RECEIVED: 20 November 2001;
ACCEPTED: 5 December 2001
The Journal of Emergency Medicine, Vol. 22, No. 4, pp. 371–374, 2002
Copyright © 2002 Elsevier Science Inc.
Printed in the USA. All rights reserved
0736-4679/02 $–see front matter
371