GESTALT THEORY
© 2016 (ISSN 0170-057 X)
Vol. 38, No.2/3, 267-278
Paolo Russo
Dramatic Perception. Foreground and Background in
Nineteenth-Century Operatic Concertatos
he study of perceptual behavior in music needs a historical and hermeneutical
approach, in order to contextualize styles and conventions which implicate the
expectations of the listener (see Meyer 1973, 109-241). In the ield of music,
subsequent elaboration of the gestalt theory has in fact shown how the basic
principles of perception are continually evolving, based on the listener’s
experience and competence (see Meyer 1956, Sloboda 1985, Guarnieri Corazzol
2004). Away from the laboratory, these principles have been reconsidered on the
basis of mental processes tied to live experience in theatres and concert halls and
interpreted as the basis of the listener’s ability to listen to music (see Guarnieri
Corazzol 2004, 63). We have had to overcome the diiculties of dividing up long
musical compositions and devise general rules for grouping within them (see
Sloboda 1985, 174-175)
1
.
It may be useful to carry out case studies of structures and musical forms with
a clear meaning which does not necessarily have to be descriptive or, in other
words, which is not limited by the painting of images or emotions conveyed
through words. In opera, for example, the music is not simply an accompaniment
and expression of a poetic text; it brings a dramatic or emotional situation
to life, through the compositional structures of the music. Indeed, musical
theatre is theatre made up of music, consisting of musical forms. A composer
creates a drama by manipulating solid musical conventions which the listener
unconsciously recognizes, having absorbed them in the course of time, rather
1
But also Bod 2002, 27: “It is widely assumed that the preferred grouping structure of a piece
depends on a combination of low-level phenomena, such as local discontinuities and intervallic
distances, and high-level phenomena, such as melodic parallelism and internal harmony. Most
models of musical segmentation use the Gestalt principles of proximity and similarity … to
predict the low-level grouping structure of a piece: grouping boundaries preferably fall on larger
inter-onset-intervals, larger pitch intervals, etc.. While most models also incorporate higher-level
grouping phenomena, such as melodic parallelism and harmony, these phenomena remain often
unformalized”. Many distinguished studies by Irène Deliège have looked at the analysis of listening
to long musical texts, among them are: Deliège & Mélen 1997. See also Hanninen 2012.