The York Play: Expanding the Boundaries of
Civic Drama
1
Sheila Christie*
University of Alberta, Canada
Abstract
While current scholarship on late medieval, civic cycle drama warns against assuming
an either antagonistic or unifying function of that drama, scholars continue to
reinscribe a conflictual relationship negotiated through cycle production. Examining
assumptions about both participants and the pageant route, this article reveals how
pre-conceived notions of the York cycle’s cultural function have limited our
interpretations of the text and context. The article concludes with a brief case study
which demonstrates that, during a time of economic recession, sources of pageant
funding expanded to include all civic labourers, altering the very conception of
‘civic’ negotiated by and through the play.
The York cycle was once considered the quintessential Corpus Christi play.
For many years, scholars assumed that this large-scale, late medieval text
represented the standard form of civic cycle drama, and that other plays of
a similar nature had simply been lost to history. The extant Chester Whitsun
plays, the N-Town and Towneley compilations, and numerous other traces
of civic cycle activity did not match the York model, but these discrepancies
were explained away as reflecting the pressures of protestant reformation
and economic recession. In recent years, however, medieval drama scholars
have realized that the York play is an unusual form of civic drama. Several
factors make the York cycle unique: the large number of pageants that
comprised the play (around fifty) and stations at which it was performed
(generally twelve, but at times as high as sixteen); the narrowness of the
streets in which performances took place; and the date and scope of
performance, which displaced the city’s Corpus Christi procession to the
following day.
2
Beyond these factors, however, the York cycle is also unique
to the city and crafts that sponsored it because it serves to negotiate multiple
conceptions of civic identity. Looking in depth at the history of pageant
sponsorship allows us to attend to these different perspectives, and to see
how the definitions of civic identity changed over time.
I begin this article by reviewing the work of other scholars who have
explored the relationship between the crafts which sponsored pageant
production and the civic authorities who authorized the play’s performance.
Earlier discussions of the cycle’s cultural function tended to characterize the
© 2007 The Author
Journal Compilation © 2007 Blackwell Publishing Ltd
History Compass 5/2 (2007): 485–494, 10.1111/j.1478-0542.2007.00421.x