Governance Issues in Delivery of Public Services
Pranab Bardhan
University of California at Berkeley
In this paper we note that the institutional context (and therefore the
structure of incentives and organisation) in developing economies is
quite different from those in advanced industrial economies, and this
necessitates any discussion on the local governance issues in the delivery
of public services in the context of development to go beyond the
traditional fiscal federalism literature. With this in mind, we review some
of the existing theoretical and empirical work, focusing particularly on the
question of local accountability.
1. Introduction
The main governance issue we focus on in this paper is decentral-
isation in the delivery of public services. In public economics there is
some discussion on this in connection with fiscal federalism, mostly
relating to the case of the USA. The principles discussed in this
literature have been fruitfully applied to developing countries like
Argentina, Brazil, Colombia, South Africa, India or China, but in this
paper we shall stress some of the special issues that arise in decentral-
isation in developing economies, primarily because the institutional
context (and therefore the structure of incentives and organisation) is
in some respects qualitatively different from that in the classical US
case (or the recent case of the European Union).
For example, much of the literature on economic efficiency of
inter-governmental competition in federalism starts with a market
metaphor that is rationalised by the well-worn Tiebout (1956) model.
Different local governments offer different public tax-expenditure
bundles and mobile individuals are supposed to allocate themselves
according to their preferences. The assumptions required for the
Tiebout model are, however, much too stringent, particularly for poor
JOURNAL OF AFRICAN ECONOMIES,VOLUME 13, AERC SUPPLEMENT 1, PP. i167–i182
Journal of African Economies Vol. 13 Suppl. 1, © Centre for the Study of
African Economies 2004; all rights reserved