The cultural patterning of respect is examined in two
first- and second-generation migrant groups: Puerto
Rican mothers in Connecticut and Turkish mothers in
Bochum, Germany. Cultural and generational influences
were found for three aspects of respect: proper interper-
sonal behavior, relations within the family, and esteem
within the community.
Exploring the Concept of Respect
Among Turkish and Puerto Rican
Migrant Mothers
Robin L. Harwood, Alev Yalçinkaya, Banu Citlak,
Birgit Leyendecker
Individualism and autonomy have been treated in numerous works over the
past two decades as primary analytical dimensions of culture that influence
parents’ child-rearing beliefs and values (Harkness, Raeff, and Super, 2000).
However, cultural analyses of the concept of respect have remained under-
specified in the literature. Often subsumed under the larger rubric of inter-
dependence (see Harwood, Miller, Carlson, and Leyendecker, 2002), respect
is itself a complex concept that needs unpacking by researchers (Harwood,
2006). A closer analysis of the concept of respect and how it may be pat-
terned across different cultural groups is a timely undertaking.
Respect is a multidimensional construct. Harwood, Miller, and Lucca
Irizarry (1995) described three dimensions of respectfulness that emerged
in their work with Puerto Rican mothers in both Puerto Rico and Connecti-
cut: (1) proper interpersonal behavior that is important to harmonious rela-
tionships, such as being polite, well behaved, and well mannered; (2) a
dimension that implicitly acknowledges the extent to which one’s life is
lived publicly in relation to a larger community, that is, “one’s life is lived
under the watchful eyes of an observing community that has the power to
9
2
NEW DIRECTIONS FOR CHILD AND ADOLESCENT DEVELOPMENT, no. 114, Winter 2006 © Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
Published online in Wiley InterScience (www.interscience.wiley.com) • DOI: 10.1002/cad.172
This research was made possible through a grant to Robin L. Harwood from the National
Institute of Child Health and Human Development.