1 Copyright © 2016 by ASME
Proceedings of the ASME 2016 International Design Engineering Technical Conferences and
Computers and Information in Engineering Conference
IDETC/CIE 2016
August 21-24, 2016, Charlotte, North Carolina, USA
IDETC2016-59494
Optimization for Anisotropy in Additively Manufactured Lattice Structures
Tino Stanković
Engineering Design and Computing Laboratory
Dept. of Mechanical and Process Engineering
ETH Zürich, Switzerland
tinos@ethz.ch
Jochen Mueller
Engineering Design and Computing Laboratory
Dept. of Mechanical and Process Engineering
ETH Zürich, Switzerland
jm@ethz.ch
Kristina Shea
Engineering Design and Computing Laboratory
Dept. of Mechanical and Process Engineering
ETH Zürich, Switzerland
kshea@ethz.ch
ABSTRACT
The build orientation of fabricated parts is one the most
influential factors affecting material properties in many
Additive Manufacturing (AM) processes. Applications such as
the optimization of lattice structures for AM, are particularly
affected as knowledge of the anisotropy model of the material
is crucial. The investigation in this paper shows the influence of
material anisotropy and build orientation on the optimized
lattice structure designs. First, a material property
characterization study for both compression and tension states
of a single material is carried out for the example of inkjet 3D
printing. Then, a generalized optimality criteria method is
extended for the optimal sizing of single material and fixed
topology lattice structures with respect to displacement, stress
and Euler buckling constraints. The stress and Euler buckling
constraints are formulated as side constraints that are handled in
combination with fully-stressed design recursion. The results
demonstrate the effect of anisotropy on the optimized designs
caused by individual struts’ build orientation. This demonstrates
the need to include anisotropic models in the optimization in
order to produce solutions that can be fabricated and tested.
1.0 INTRODUCTION
The build orientation of additively manufactured (AM)
parts plays an important role in the optimization of lattice
structures for inkjet 3D printing and any AM process with
known anisotropic material properties. Knowledge of the
anisotropy model of the material is crucial since the local load
direction in each strut differs based on the topology and rotating
the whole structure rotates all struts. In a recently published
article, it has been shown that the effect of build orientation of
3D printed parts from the inkjet 3D printing process is non-
linear [1]. Due to interactions among many struts and non-
linear material properties in a three-dimensional space, the
optimization of such structures is not trivial and accurate
material data is required. It has also been shown that the
weakest mechanical properties are not only found along the z-
axis, as assumed in many other works, but at an angle of
approximately 45° in relation to the three axes of the printers’
coordinate system as shown in [1][2]. This discovery is
particularly important for lattice structures where different
angles of the discrete struts in the structure always occur and
thus their axial loads are also at many different angles in the
structure.
Lattice structures are growing in interest due to their
favorable strength-to-weight ratio allowing for efficient load
carrying and energy absorption properties [3][4]. Multi-material
lattices are beneficial because they can alter the product’s
performance capabilities without altering the dimensions of the
topology and individual struts [5]. Optimizing for anisotropy in
such complex structures with often hundreds or thousands of
members is, however, a large-scale optimization problem. Few
methods exist to deal with such large-scale optimization
problems for AM, most notably is the application of the
optimality criteria as demonstrated in the recent publications by
Stanković et al. [5] and [6] to tackle the problem of optimal