ELSEVIER
HhS0955-7997(98)00004-6
Engineering Analysis with Boundary Elements 21 (1998) 81-85
© 1998 Published by Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved
Printed in Great Britain
0955-7997/981519.00
Research Note
Axisymmetric augmented thin plate splines
v
Bo~,idar Sarler
Laboratory for Fluid Dynamics and Thermodynamics, Faculty of Mechanical Engineering, University of Ljubljana, Agker~eva 6, 1000
Ljubljana, Slovenia
This paper reviews the previous axisymmetric global interpolation functions used in
the context of the dual reciprocity boundary element method and the axisymmetric
Laplace operator. It upgrades the previous heuristic attempts with the axisymmetdc
form of the augmented thin plate splines. This new approach, based on the theory of
radial basis functions, gives more formal mathematical support to this class of
problems. The basic equations are accompanied by a set of related expressions that
permit straightforward use of the developed global interpolation functions in a broad
spectrum of dual reciprocity boundary element methods like discrete approximative
procedures. © 1998 Published by Elsevier Science Ltd. All fights reserved
Key words: Boundary element method, radial basis functions, augmented thin plate
splines, axisymmetry.
1 INTRODUCTION
Axisymmetric geometry and field problems occur very
frequently in science and engineering. The discrete approx-
imative solutions of the different governing equations in
such situations are of pronottnced importance.
The fusion of the boundary element method and global
interpolation emerges in a variety of dual reciprocity
boundary element (DRBEM) discrete approximative
procedures 1'2 which give reasonable evaluations of the
governing equations. Recently, two very comprehensive
overviews have been published 3'4 regarding the use of the
different global approximation functions in the BEM con-
text. However, the mathematical properties of such methods
are nowadays far from being ,;ufficiently understood. Because
of the unresolved theoretical answers to related existence,
uniqueness, convergence and stability issues, many numeri-
cal experiments and comparisons have been traditionally
made in an ad-hoc manner in the DRBEM literature.
The problem of global interpolation outside of the BEM
context has been much more closely investigated mathema-
tically. 5 Corresponding analyses show that the use of the
radial basis class of functions represents a proper choice
for multidimensional global interpolation. Most of the
related advances focus on the augmented thin plate splines
(ATPS) and multiquadrics (lVlQ). The ATPS are known to
give the minimized curvature of the interpolation and the
MQ could, depending on the choice of the free parameter,
converge very rapidly. Karur and Ramachadran 6 first gave
81
DRBEM numerical examples with ATPS and claim a superior
solution to the heuristic 'one-plus-r' global approximation
functions in two-dimensional planar problems. Very recently,
Golberg et al. 7 used MQ in a method of fundamental
solutions, a variant of the BEM with global interpolation.
They demonstrate up to three orders of magnitude of
improvement in accuracy over ATPS and 'one-plus-r' func-
tions provided that the free parameter is properly chosen.
Surprisingly, not many DRBEM solutions structured with
the fundamental solution of the Laplace equation deal with
axisymmetric problems. In the pioneering work concerning
this DRBEM aspect, Wrobel and Telles s heuristically use
the global approximation functions of the form
9~/n [(,Pp- Pnp) 2 -Jr- (Pz ,2~1/2 ( lpp~
= -Pnz) J 1- (1)
4 pnp/
with the notation elaborated in the next chapter. Masse6
and Marcouiller9 found this function inadequate and after
several numerical experiments proposed
2 2
9~J/n = Pnp [ (Pp -- Pno)2 + (Pz -- Pnz) ] (Po [ (Po -- Pnp)
+-- ,2]1/2 + 3~
(Pz --Pnz) PO) (2)
with P0 representing a small positive constant which was
set to 0.01.
The principal incitement for this paper is the fact that the
axisymmetric form of ATPS and MQ have not yet been
deduced. The present paper thus focuses on a relatively
complex derivation of the axisymmetric ATPS and related