Sociology
1–16
© The Author(s) 2017
Reprints and permissions:
sagepub.co.uk/journalsPermissions.nav
DOI: 10.1177/0038038516677221
soc.sagepub.com
Young Pakistani Men and
Irish Identity: Religion, Race
and Ethnicity in Post-Celtic
Tiger Ireland
Craig Considine
Rice University, USA
Abstract
This article contributes to the discussion on Irish identity by considering a set of empirical data
from ethnographic research carried out in Pakistani communities in Dublin. The article considers
views on ‘Irishness’ through the lens of young second-generation Pakistani Irish men. The data
presented highlight how the Celtic Tiger experience reproduced cultural and ethnic narratives
of Irish identity, but simultaneously initiated a new, more civic-oriented view of ‘Irishness’.
Of particular concern in the minds of young Pakistani men include the secularisation of Irish
society and the role that ‘whiteness’ plays in processes of ‘othering’ in Ireland. The article reveals
that the current period of Irish history provides an opportunity for the Pakistani Irish to challenge
some of the assumptions currently associated with Irish identity. Ultimately, the article calls for
a broader understanding of Irish identity through the lens of civic national principles, which can
better serve Ireland’s increasingly diverse population.
Keywords
Celtic Tiger, Irishness, race and ethnicity, religion, Pakistanis
Introduction
‘What does it mean to be Irish?’ This question has no simple answer. Irish identity is
a complex concept that is ingrained in colonial/post-colonial narratives and struggles
for national independence. Recently, efforts to define ‘Irishness’ have accelerated due
largely to the Celtic Tiger experience (1994–2010) (White, 2008: 82). The term Celtic
Tiger arose out of a period of economic growth similar in size and scale to that experi-
enced by the Tiger economies of South-East Asia (Smyth, 2012: 132). Like in South
Corresponding author:
Craig Considine, Department of Sociology, Rice University, Houston, TX 77005, USA.
Email: craig.m.considine@rice.edu
677221SOC 0 0 10.1177/0038038516677221SociologyConsidine
research-article 2017
Article