NARROWBAND INTERFERENCE SUPPRESSION IN MULTI-BAND OFDM ULTRA
WIDEBAND COMMUNICATION SYSTEMS: A MIXED-MODE APPROACH
Burak Kelleci, Timothy W. Fischer, Kai Shi, Yi Zhou, Aydın
˙
Ilker Kars ¸ılayan and Erchin Serpedin
Department of Electrical Engineering
Texas A&M University, College Station, TX 77843-3128
serpedin@ece.tamu.edu
ABSTRACT
To avoid significant losses that might be induced by a narrow-
band interference (NBI) on the performance of a multi-band (MB)
OFDM ultra wideband (UWB) receiver, efficient NBI mitigation
schemes are required. This paper proposes a novel mixed-mode
NBI suppression scheme that relies on the cooperation between
a digital NBI detector and an adaptive analog notch filter. Sim-
ulation results show that the proposed mixed-mode suppression
scheme improves the performance of the digital frequency exci-
sion scheme in a MB-OFDM UWB receiver by as much as an
equivalent signal-to-interference ratio gain of 9 dB.
1. INTRODUCTION
Ultra-wideband (UWB) transceivers hold the promise to revolu-
tionize the next generation of short-range wireless networks. For
the UWB transceivers to coexist with nearby devices, it is neces-
sary to design efficient UWB receivers whose operation is robust
to narrowband interferences (NBI). References [1]–[3] outline the
most relevant NBI mitigation schemes, which can be broadly clas-
sified into two main groups. The first class of methods is moti-
vated by the fact that the received signal consists of a correlated
NBI and an uncorrelated spread spectrum signal. A pre-whitening
filter [3]–[5] can be used to reduce the correlation of the received
signal, and thus to suppress the NBI. The pre-whitening filter is
found to improve the performance of spread spectrum receivers
especially when the interference is strong [3]. However, the un-
derlying assumption required by this class of methods can not be
further extended to multi-band OFDM based UWB transceivers
since the OFDM signal is correlated during one symbol period.
When compared to the desired wideband signal, the interfer-
ence occupies a much smaller frequency band and presents a higher
power spectral density. Motivated by this fact, the second class
of methods relies on transform domain filtering techniques to sup-
press the NBI. By converting the received signal into the frequency
domain via real-time transform devices [4], one can easily deter-
mine the frequency location of NBI. The part of the signal cor-
rupted by NBI is excised in the frequency domain and the remain-
ing signal is re-transformed into the time domain. This method
appears to be also fit for NBI suppression in OFDM receivers.
In this paper, a mixed-mode (hybrid) interference mitigation
scheme that consists of a digital NBI detector and an adaptive ana-
log notch filter (AANF) is proposed. Our study shows that such
This work was supported in part by the Texas Higher Education Coor-
dinating Board and NSF.
mixed schemes could be applied with success to combat strong
NBI (i.e., interferences that give rise to signal-to-interference ra-
tios (SIR) less than 0 dB) in multi-band (MB) OFDM UWB re-
ceivers. It is also found that for combating mild interferences (i.e.,
those interferences for which SIR ≥ 0 dB), it is sufficient to con-
sider a low-complexity digital frequency excision method. Our
comprehensive simulations show that in the presence of strong
NBI, a mixed mode NBI mitigation scheme provides a significant
gain (an equivalent SIR gain of 9 dB) relative to a receiver that as-
sumes only a digital frequency excision method. In the following
sections, operation of the digital and analog suppression schemes
are discussed, and the performance of the mixed-mode NBI miti-
gation system is demonstrated.
2. DIGITAL NBI DETECTION AND MITIGATION
The detection of NBI requires a fast Fourier transform (FFT) de-
vice, which is already present in an OFDM receiver. Since the
phase of NBI is unknown, the NBI has to be detected noncoher-
ently based on the absolute values of the received signal samples.
Without any loss of generality, the NBI is modeled as a complex
sinusoid with unknown amplitude, frequency and phase [6]. For
flat-fading channels the highest peak corresponds to the subcarrier
affected by NBI. Therefore, by comparing the magnitude-squared
of the FFT bins |X[k]|
2
with a threshold T0, one can easily find
out not only the existence of NBI but also the subcarrier location
of NBI. The performance of the NBI detector depends on the value
of threshold: a too small T0 could lead to large false alarms, while
a larger T0 could increase the probability of a miss. In general,
the Neyman-Pearson detection framework could be used to opti-
mize the value of threshold T0. In frequency-selective channels
the OFDM signal presents a large dynamic range, and some signal
peaks could take values close to the peak induced by NBI. This
observation indicates that the detection of NBI becomes difficult
in frequency-selective channels, especially when the SIR is large.
Fortunately, in packet-oriented UWB systems, for most of the time
the channel is clear of the transmitted signal. To avoid the effects
introduced by the OFDM signal, we may detect the NBI during the
time interval between the two packets.
Since the subcarriers corrupted by NBI are not reliable any-
more, they should not be used during the demodulation. The meth-
od of erasing the corrupted subcarriers is referred to as frequency
excision, and the lost data caused by excision can be recovered
by exploiting channel decoding techniques. To evaluate the per-
formance of the frequency excision method, we run simulations
assuming an MB-OFDM receiver. It is well known that, due to
55 1-4244-0535-1/06/$20.00/©2006 IEEE