Full Length Research Article
UNIVERSITY STUDENTS’ PERCEPTIONS OF HAZING: A GENDER APPROACH
*1
Suzana Nunes Caldeira,
1
Osvaldo Silva,
2
Maria Mendes,
2
Susana Botelho
and
3
Maria José D. Martins
1
University of Azores, CICS.UAc/CICS.NOVA.UAc, Portugal
2
University of Azores, Portugal
3
Polythenic Institute of Portalegre, Portugal
ARTICLE INFO ABSTRACT
The initiation rituals that freshmen are subjected to in universities have been characterized quite
differently, although the most frequent view is that it is a rough experience for those coming to
higher education for the first time. Gender has emerged as a differentiating variable of how
students experience this practice. In this study, our interest is to find out the perceptions of
university students over the events that take place during the entry to higher education through a
comparative gender analysis. The sample included247 students of both genders. Data were
collected by means of the scale ‘Evaluation of Bullying Situations in Higher Education Hazing’,
which consists of 15 items and three factors: ‘positive relationship with hazing’, ‘negative
relationship with hazing’ and ‘social dimension’. Findings indicate that, in the overall scale, there
are significant differences between genders, with boys expressing a stronger agreement with the
practice. In the analysis by dimension, this fact is reinforced, since in the ‘positive relationship
with hazing’, boys exhibit significantly higher results than girls. In the distribution of variables in
the two-dimensional space (CatPCA), we witness that, despite agreeing with hazing practices,
boys display a very heterogeneous behavior, while girls more homogeneously disagree with them.
Copyright©2016, Suzana Nunes Caldeira et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits
unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
INTRODUCTION
The transition from secondary education to higher education
connects two relatively distinct periods in a student’s career,
since it requires the departure from one cycle of general
studies and the integration into a new context more linked to
the establishment of career goals. This transition is
experienced by youngsters with happiness for having achieved
a coveted goal, but also with anxiety for starting a new phase
in their lives in a context that they still do not known and
control. Some aspects associated with the entry to higher
education can facilitate this transition and the students’
adaptation to the challenges of the new academic environment.
In particular, relationships appear with some frequency in the
literature on this topic (Abrantes, 2005; Agante, 2009; Leary
and DeRosier, 2012), with peers playing a prominent role in
relaying a welcoming message and in accepting the new
element intothe academic culture.
*Corresponding author: Suzana Nunes Caldeira,
University of Azores, CICS.UAc/CICS.NOVA.UAc, Portugal
It is within this understanding that hazing, which is
traditionally called praxe in Portugal, is sometimes presented
by veteran students (Vieira, 2013) as a means of socialising, so
newcomers and veterans can interact with the aim of getting to
know each other, establishing new friendships and guiding
freshmen in academic activities (Schmalzer, 2013). Although
we can recognise that, in many cases, there is a positive
intention associated with hazing, the reports of several
students subjected to it tend not to validate this favourable and
humanitarian view of the events as the most common one.
Often the alleged reception events are described as
manifestations of power and abuse of veteran students over
freshmen (Hoover and Milner, 1998; Mikell, 2014; Nirh,
2014) in which secrecy and silence characterise the dynamics
that take place (Allan and Madden, 2008). Feeling some
insecurity about their future in the new context and fearing
social exclusion from peer groups or other forms of retaliation,
newcomers tend to give up their personal identity (Tajfel,
1983; Tajfel and Turner, 1979) and to tolerate these abuses,
subjecting themselves to different forms and degrees of
violence (Allan and Madden, 2008; Hoover and Milner,
ISSN: 2230-9926 International Journal of Development Research
Vol. 06, Issue, 09, pp.9444-9449, September, 2016
International Journal of
DEVELOPMENT RESEARCH
Article History:
Received 29
th
June, 2016
Received in revised form
12
th
July, 2016
Accepted 19
th
August, 2016
Published online 30
th
September, 2016
Available online at http://www.journalijdr.com
Key Words:
Hazing;
Gender Violence;
Socialisation practices.