. . . . . Health Disparities . . . . .
ABSTRACT: Context: Hispanics are at increased risk for
diabetes, while rural residents have historically had
decreased access to care. Purpose: To determine whether
living in a rural area and being Hispanic confers special
risks for diagnosis and control of diabetes. Methods: We
analyzed the Third National Health and Nutrition
Examination Survey (1988-1994). Hispanics and non-
Hispanic white adults were classified according to rural/
urban residence to create 4 ethnicity-residence groups.
Investigated outcomes were previously diagnosed and
undiagnosed diabetes. Among those with diagnosed
diabetes, we investigated control of glucose, hypertension,
and lipids. Findings: The prevalence of diagnosed
diabetes was greatest for rural residents, especially for
rural Hispanics (8.2%) versus that for urban whites
(4.6%), rural whites (6.5%), or urban Hispanics (4.5%),
(P < .01). However, urban Hispanics were most likely to
have undiagnosed diabetes at 3.7%, versus 2.3% of rural
whites, 2.8% of urban whites, and 2.7% of rural
Hispanics (P = .04). Among people with diagnosed
diabetes, there was no difference in glycemic control
between the 4 groups. Rural Hispanics with diagnosed
diabetes had the greatest prevalence of elevated systolic
blood pressure at 45%, compared to 37% of urban whites,
29% of rural whites, 28% of urban Hispanics (P = .01).
In regression models controlling for potential
confounders, there were no differences among urban and
rural whites and Hispanics in the likelihood of
undiagnosed diabetes or in glycemic control for those with
diagnosed diabetes. Conclusions: Initiatives that target
Hispanic health, and especially diabetes, should
acknowledge rural/urban Hispanic health differences.
1
Department of Family Medicine, Medical University of South
Carolina, Charleston, SC.
Supported by a grant from the Office of Rural Health Policy, grant
5 P30 AG21677 from the National Institute on Aging/National
Institutes of Health, and grant 1D12HP00023-01 from the Health
Resources and Services Administration. For further information,
contact: Richelle J. Koopman, MD, MS, Department of Family
Medicine, Medical University of South Carolina, 295 Calhoun St, PO
Box 250192, Charleston, SC 29425; e-mail koopmanr@musc.edu.
Rural Residence and Hispanic Ethnicity: Doubly
Disadvantaged for Diabetes?
Richelle J. Koopman, MD, MS;
1
Arch G. Mainous III, PhD;
1
and Mark E. Geesey, MS
1
diabetes for Mexican Americans in the United States
was more than double that of white, non-Hispanic
Americans (11.7% compared to 4.8%).
1
Rural and minority populations have historically had
problems accessing care and are particularly vulnerable to
the consequences of lower access to care.
5-10
Limited
access to health care services results in fewer medical
visits, underdiagnosis, lower rates of recommended
monitoring tests for diabetes, and less optimal health
outcomes.
11-15
Reducing access-to-care disparities can lead
to improved outcomes indistinguishable from fully
insured persons with full access.
16,17
Being minority and living in a rural area may have
particular implications for access to health care.
Evidence exists that there is an interaction between race
and rural residence for health care outcomes. Although
women in rural areas are less likely than urban women
to have had a recent Pap test,
8
some data indicate that
rural and urban white women are not different in their
likelihood of receiving a Pap test, while rural African
American women are less likely than urban African
Americans to be screened.
18
Similarly, in a study of the
relationship between race and rural/urban residence
and diabetes control comparing whites and African
Americans, rural African Americans with diabetes
were significantly less likely than urban or rural whites
to have optimal glycemic control.
19
Although the data suggest that Hispanics are
more likely to have diabetes and that individuals
living in rural areas have decreased access to care, it is
unclear if being both Hispanic and living in a rural
D
iabetes mellitus is a common and
potentially disabling chronic disease,
affecting more than 16 million people in
the United States.
1
Persons with diabetes
are at increased risk for a number of
serious complications, including retinopathy, renal
disease, and heart disease.
2-4
Diabetes is a disease
with substantial health disparities. For example, the
1999-2000 age- and sex-adjusted rate of diagnosed
© 2006 National Rural Health Association 63 Winter 2006