Fertilizer Research 39: 77-82, 1994.
© 1994 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
Wheat growth from phosphorus fertilizers as affected by time and method of
application in soil with an acidic subsurface layer
E. Purnomo & A. S. Black
School of Agriculture, Charles Sturt University, P.O. Box 588 Wagga Wagga, NSW 2678, Australia
Received 7 April 1993; accepted in revised form 4 May 1994
Key words: Acidic subsurface layer, application rate, North Carolina phosphate rock, placement method, time of
application, triple superphosphate, wheat
Abstract
Using soils with an acidic subsurface layer, three glasshouse experiments were carried out to evaluate the effect of
placement method and application rate of triple superphosphate (TSP) and North Carolina phosphate rock (NCPR)
on dry matter (DM) yields. Time of application of NCPR on DM yield response of wheat was also studied.
For Experiment 1, soil was collected in depth intervals of 0-2; 4-6; 6-8; and 8-10 cm from a red earth (chromic
luvisol). The treatments included two P sources (TSP and NCPR), three placement methods (broadcast, banded or
mixed into the subsurface layer, 6-8 cm), and six application rates. In this P deficient soil with an acidic subsurface
layer, there was relatively little effect of application method of TSP on wheat yield responses. The maximum
dry matter yield responses for broadcast, band and mix application methods was 30, 42 and 50 %, respectively.
Responses to NCPR broadcast, band and mix methods were 20, 9 and 44 %, respectively. Mixing NCPR into to
acidic subsurface layer produced yields similar to those from TSP although a higher application rate of P as NCPR
was needed to achieve this outcome.
Treatments for Experiments 2 and 3 were time of application of NCPR (0 and 30 days before sowing) and rate of
application of NCPR (0 and 40 mg P/pot). In Experiment 2 (same soil as Experiment 1) application of NCPR prior
to sowing, resulted in higher Colwell P concentration than when applied at sowing, but time of application had
no effect on final DM yields. Experiment 3 used a red podzolic (chromic luvisol) soil which had a lower P-status,
was more acid and had a lower exchangeable Ca 2+ concentration than the red earth. Application of NCPR prior to
sowing resulted in lower DM yield than when it was applied prior to sowing.
Introduction
The most effective economic procedures for fertilizer
application need to be adopted in Australia, because
the soils are P deficient. Normally P deficiency is over-
come using water soluble single superphosphate fertil-
izer (SSP). This fertilizer is applied to crops by drilling
at a depth between 2 and 5 cm. The combination of
drilling in bands and application at sowing generally
have given the best yield responses from SSP (Rudd
and Barrow, 1973).
Many soils in south eastern Australia have become
acid (Helyar and Porter, 1989). Within the acid surface
soil an acidic subsurface layer developed (Conyers and
Scott, 1989). Soil in the 2 to 10 cm depth interval
(subsurface layer) was 0.63 to 1.18 pH units lower
than that in the 0 to 2 cm depth. Direct drilling results
in fertilizer being placed into this acidic subsurface
layer. Under acidic conditions, availability of soluble
P fertilizer decreases rapidly. Application of SSP in
the less acidic surface (0 to 2 cm) may be a desirable
practice.
An alternative P source for acidic soils is reactive
phosphate rock (PR). Best agronomic responses have
been obtained when PR was incorporated throughout
the soil with pH(H20) of less than 6 (Boltand and
Gilkes, 1990). Our hypothesis is that incorporation
of PR in the acidic subsurface layers may increase P
availability compared with mixing throughout the soil.