Frostbite of both irst digits of the foot treated with delayed hyperbaric
oxygen: A case report and review of literature
Tom C.P.M. Kemper M.Sc.
1
, Vincent M. de Jong M.D.
2
, Helen A. Anema Ph.D.
3
, Albert van den Brink M.D.
1
,
Robert A. van Hulst M.D. Ph.D.
1,4
1
Department of Hyperbaric Medicine and Laboratory Experimental Intensive Care Anesthesiology,
Academic Medical Center, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
2
Department of Trauma Surgery, Academic Medical Center, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
3
Department of Public Health, Academic Medical Center, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
4
Diving Medical Center, Royal Netherlands Navy, Den Helder, The Netherlands
CORRESPONDING AUTHOR: Tom C.P.M. Kemper – t.kemper@icloud.com
UHM 2014, VOL. 41, NO. 1 – HBO
2
fOR THE TREATMENT Of fROSTBITE
______________________________________________________________________________________________
ABSTRACT
Background: Frostbite is an uncommon event that
can occur from exposure to temperatures below
-4°C and can lead to potential serious tissue damage
and necrosis. This in turn can result in debilitating
amputations in otherwise healthy people. The patho-
physiological mechanisms of frostbite have marked
similarities to those seen in thermal burns, ischemia/
reperfusion injuries and crush injuries — i.e., non-
healing wounds and inlammatory processes. These
injuries are commonly treated with hyperbaric oxygen
therapy.
Objectives: Evidence for treating frostbite with hyper-
baric oxygen (HBO
2
) is scarce, and to date HBO
2
is not a standard addition in the multidisciplinary
care of freezing injuries. We aim to contribute to the
available evidence with a case report and review the
literature to reassess the multidisciplinary treatment
of frostbite injuries.
Case report and review of literature: We present a
case report of a woman with deep frostbite of the toes
treated with hyperbaric oxygen therapy, after a delay
of 21 days, with good results. No surgical intervention
was needed. A literature search revealed 17 human
case reports on frostbite and four animal studies in
which hyperbaric oxygen was applied. All case
reports showed positive effects, and in none of
the cases was amputation necessary. In the animal
studies, two showed signiicant positive results
regarding tissue loss and reduction of inlammatory
markers, whereas two did not.
Conclusions: Based on our case report as well as
the literature and the mechanisms of hyperbaric
oxygen, we make the recommendation that this
therapy be considered as an addition to the multi-
disciplinary treatment of frostbite, even after signi-
icant delay of treatment.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
65
Copyright © 2014 Undersea & Hyperbaric Medical Society, Inc.
INTRODUCTION
frostbite is an uncommon but potentially serious event
that can occur from exposure to temperatures below
-4°C and can lead to extensive tissue damage in other-
wise healthy people who are (most likely) part of the
working and sporting population [1]. Despite the increase
in persons at risk (due, for example, to outdoor activ-
ities [2], homelessness [3]), data on the incidence and
morbidity are scarce, large randomized clinical trials
are not yet feasible and standard treatment guidelines
based on a high level of evidence are lacking.
A recent treatment guideline from the Wilderness
Medical Society was based on a (systematic) literature-
guided consensus process, encompassing a large num-
ber of international frostbite experts [4]. With respect to
hyperbaric oxygen (HBO
2
) therapy it was concluded
that, despite anecdotal evidence of positive effects in
a few case reports [1,5,6], due to the absence of con-
trolled trials the data are insuficient to recommend
HBO
2
therapy for frostbite.
To contribute to the knowledge on treatment of this
type of injury, we present a report of frostbite injury
treated with HBO
2
after a relatively long delay of 21
days. Also provided is an overview of the literature on
the effectiveness of hyperbaric oxygen therapy in
humans and in animal studies.