DOI: 10.1007/s00339-005-3209-1
Appl. Phys. A 81, 57–63 (2005)
Materials Science & Processing
Applied Physics A
j. jalbert
1,2, ✉
r. lacasse
2
m.a. el khakani
1
r. gilbert
2
Accelerated ageing of wood Kraft insulating
paper by means of a pulsed KrF excimer
laser radiation
1
Institut National de la Recherche Scientifique, INRS-
´
Energie, Mat´ eriaux et T´ el´ ecommunications,
1650, boulevard Lionel-Boulet, Varennes, Qu´ ebec, J3X 1S2 Canada
2
Institut de Recherche d’Hydro-Qu´ ebec (IREQ), 1800, boulevard Lionel-Boulet, Varennes, Qu´ ebec,
J3X 1S1 Canada
Received: 9 July 2004 /Accepted: 20 December 2004
Published online: 2 March 2005 • © Springer-Verlag 2005
ABSTRACT We report on the successful use of a KrF excimer
laser as a highly promising tool to investigate the accelerated
ageing of wood Kraft papers used as insulating components in
high-voltage power transformers. The effects of varying both
the laser repetition rate (5 to 180 Hz) and the laser energy dens-
ity (0.02 to 0.11 J cm
−2
) on the degradation of wood Kraft paper
in air were systematically investigated. During the laser irradi-
ation experiments, the temperature of the paper samples was
real-time measured by means of an IR camera. It is shown
that the ageing temperature of the paper can be controlled
very precisely by simply adjusting the laser parameters. In-
deed, levelling-off temperatures in the 25–320
◦
C range can be
reached after only 3 s of laser exposure, by either varying the
repetition rate at a fixed energy density or changing the laser
fluence at a given pulse rate. By performing both scanning elec-
tron microscopy (SEM) observations and measurements of the
degree of polymerization ( DP
v
) of the laser irradiated paper
samples, we were able to demonstrate that the laser irradiation
induces a very rapid degradation of the paper samples (typi-
cal laser exposure times are around 35 s to be compared with
∼10 days for standard dynamic heating based ageing tests).
Both the DP
v
of the irradiated paper samples and the average
width of the corresponding cellulose fibers as measured from
SEM micrographs, are shown to reduce by about 50% follow-
ing their laser heating at ∼ 320
◦
C for 35 s of exposure time.
It is pointed out that the observed laser-induced degradation is
predominantly a photothermal process. Finally, by using gas
chromatography/mass spectrometry (GC/MS), we were able to
show that low molecular weight compounds such as acetalde-
hyde, methyl formate, acetone, and methanol are produced not
only by the laser ageing process but also in real on-field trans-
formers that underwent a severe short-circuit.
PACS 42.62.-b; 61.80.Ba; 83.80.Mc; 84.70.+p
1 Introduction
Owing to their excellent insulating properties and
low cost, wood Kraft papers have long been used by elec-
trical utilities as the insulating material of choice in high-
voltage (HV) power transformers. The main constituent is
✉ Fax: +1-450-652-8424, E-mail: jalbert.jocelyn@ireq.ca
cellulose, a linear homopolymer composed of cyclic β-D-
glucopyranosyl units jointed by C-1−O−C-4
′
glycosidic
bonds. Due to a combination of oxidative, hydrolytic, and
thermal degradation mechanisms that affect all cellulose-
based materials, the degradation of the insulating paper be-
came a source of concern for utilities as equipment ages. As
a result of this action, the average degree of polymerization of
the cellulose (averaged number of cyclic β-D-glucopyranosyl
units in the cellulose molecular chains) decreases asymptot-
ically from an original value of about 1000 units to a lim-
iting value in the region of 200. At this stage, paper with
20% of its original tensile strength is recognized as being at
the end of its useful life [1]. In open-breathing HV power
transformers which typically contain ∼ 11 tons of paper and
pressboard, and up to 45 tons of oil, these papers in con-
tact with an oxygen-saturated mineral oil may present up to
about 2 (w/w) % of moisture and, depending upon opera-
tional conditions, may be exposed to temperatures ranging
from 60 to 110
◦
C. Under such conditions, it is known that
the prevailing degradation mechanisms involve the hydroly-
sis of the molecular chains and the oxidation of the primary
C-6 and secondary C-2 and C-3 hydroxyl groups of the β-D-
glucopyranosyl units, both leading to the scission of the gly-
cosidic bonds [2]. To track the depolymerization of cellulose
in equipment, it is then important to identify the species that
form following the scission of glycosidic bonds. In addition,
these volatile species should possess partitioning characteris-
tics that will favor their migration into the oil phase in order to
be easily accessible for subsequent analyses. Information on
the accumulation of such chemical indicators in the oil is es-
sential for elaborating a predictive strategy that would guide
the replacement planning of operating electrical units beyond
their nominal design life.
Until now, two main accelerated-ageing methods have
been employed to examine the influence of temperature, oxy-
gen, and moisture on the degradation of insulating papers and
the resulting end-products. The first and most widely used
method consists of carrying out heat-rise isothermal ageing
tests on samples in air [3–7]. The main interest of this method
is that it provides strict control over the environmental condi-
tions such as the temperature and the initial moisture and oxy-
gen contents of the samples. However, when the low tempera-
tures are tested, i.e. 50–70
◦
C, it can take several months and
even years to significantly decrease the degree of polymer-