Using overseas registered nurses to fill employment gaps in
rural health services: Quick fix or sustainable strategy?
Karen Francis,
1
Ysanne Chapman,
1
Glenn Doolan,
2
Ken Sellick
1
and Tony Barnett
1
1
School of Nursing and Midwifery, Monash University, Churchill, and
2
Department of Epidemiology
and Preventative Medicine, Monash University, Burnett Tower, Alfred Hospital, Prahan, Victoria,
Australia
Abstract
Objective: This study sought to identify and evaluate
approaches used to attract internationally trained nurses
from traditional and non-traditional countries and
incentives employed to retain them in small rural
hospitals in Gippsland, Victoria.
Design: An exploratory descriptive design.
Setting: Small rural hospitals in Gippsland, Victoria.
Participants: Hospital staff responsible for recruitment
of nurses and overseas trained nurses from traditional
and non-traditional sources (e.g. England, Scotland,
India, Zimbabwe, Holland, Singapore, Malaysia).
Results and Conclusion: Recruitment of married over-
seas trained nurses is more sustainable than that of
single registered nurses, however, the process of recruit-
ment for the hospital and potential employees is costly.
Rural hospitality diffuses some of these expenses by the
employing hospitals providing emergency accommoda-
tion and necessary furnishings. Cultural differences and
dissonance regarding practice create barriers for some of
the overseas trained nurses to move towards a more
sanguine position. On the positive side, single overseas
registered nurses use the opportunity to work in rural
Australian hospitals as an effective working holiday that
promotes employment in larger, more specialized hospi-
tals. Overall both the registered nurses and the employ-
ees believe the experience to be beneficial rather than
detrimental.
KEY WORDS: recruitment, retention, overseas regis-
tered nurse, rural.
Introduction
A shortage of rural registered nurses (RNs) now exists
in most countries across the world. Australia, North
America and Europe are some of the industrialised
nations experiencing escalating nursing shortages and
an associated significant upward trend in the inflow of
overseas-born nurses. Australia, the United Kingdom
(UK) and the United States of America (USA) are the
countries receiving the largest number of overseas
trained nurses (OTNs).
Registration data from the Australian Nursing Mid-
wifery Council,
1
the Department of Immigration and
Multicultural Affairs (DIMA) and state nursing boards
indicate that the overall trend in inflow of nurses to
Australia has been upwards in recent years, but with
significant variation between states.
2,3
There appears to
be a current heavy reliance on recruitment from the
Europe, Scandinavia, North America and Pacific coun-
tries.
4
Between 1995 and 2000 Australia received
11 757 foreign nurses, possibly outstripping even USA,
which received more than 10 000. UK is even further
ahead, admitting 26 286 foreign nurses between 1998
and 2003.
5
By 1996 almost 25% of nurses employed in
Australia were born outside Australia: 11.2% in UK or
Ireland, 3.9% in Asian countries, 2.8% in New
Zealand, 2.5% in ‘other Europe’ and 3.3% in ‘other’
countries.
6
Of late rural hospitals in Victoria have had
difficulties recruiting nurses from the more traditional
countries such as USA and UK and successful recruit-
ment has occurred with nurses from other (non-
traditional) countries such as Malaysia, Singapore and
African countries.
Potential barriers to international nurse recruitment
and mobility form part of the international debate, and
are discussed in the literature by Seccombe and Buchan
7
and Snyder and Bunkers.
8
There is relatively little pub-
lished research on the motivation of nurses for moving
between countries, and a need has been identified to
explore the factors which determine the choice of des-
tination for English-speaking nurses, who have several
options.
9
There is growing body of literature available
on overseas trained medical doctor recruitment and
retention.
10–14
This body of literature highlights positive
and negative features of working in rural environments
that impact on medical doctor recruitment and reten-
tion. Issues such as being able to maintain cultural
Correspondence: Associate Professor Ysanne Chapman,
School of Nursing and Midwifery, Monash University, North-
ways Road, Churchill, Victoria, 3842, Australia. Email:
ysanne.chapman@med.monash.edu.au
Accepted for publication 1 June 2007.
Aust. J. Rural Health (2008) 16, 164–169
© 2008 The Authors
Journal Compilation © 2008 National Rural Health Alliance Inc. doi: 10.1111/j.1440-1584.2008.00967.x