~ Pergamon
0887-2333(94)E0006-F
Toxic'. in Vitro Vol. 8, No. 3, pp. 317-328, 1994
Copyright © 1994 ElsevierScienceLtd
Printed in Great Britain. All rights reserved
0887-2333/94 $7.00 + 0.00
EFFECTS OF AFLATOXIN B~ IN A LIVER CELL LINE
FROM RAINBOW TROUT (ONCORHYNCHUS MYKISS)
D. G. BECHTEL and L. E. J. LEE*
Department of Veterinary Anatomy, Western College of Veterinary Medicine,
University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, SK, Canada S7N 0W0
(Received 30 September 1993; revisions received 18 November 1993)
Abstract--The cytotoxic response to ariatoxin B 1 (AFB) was investigated in RTL-W1, a cell line derived
from the normal liver of a mature rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss). AFB altered RTL-Wl
morphology and ultrastructure and inhibited DNA synthesis. The effective concentration required for
50% inhibition (ECs0) of DNA synthesis, after 2 days of treatment was 0.04 #g/ml. This response was
compared with that of two other salmonid, but non-liver, cell lines [rainbow trout gonad (RTG-2) and
Chinook salmon embryo (CHSE-214)]. Although RTG-2 cells were as sensitive as RTL-W1 cells (ECs0
for inhibition of DNA synthesis was 0.05 pg/ml), CHSE-214 cells were unresponsive to AFB at
concentrations as high as 2 # g/ml. After a single AFB exposure, RTL-W1 sublines were isolated that had
phenotypic changes typical of malignant transformation. These were increased growth rate, reduced
contact inhibition of growth, altered cellular morphology and growth in soft agar. In addition, RTL-Wl
metabolized AFB: the major metabolites, aflatoxin (AFL) and aflatoxin MI (AFM), were detected by
thin-layer chromatography and HPLC. The relative amounts of these metabolites, unlike those observed
with RTG-2 cells, were in close agreement with those produced by trout liver in vivo. Thus, RTL-W 1 could
provide a sensitive in vitro model system for studying the action of biotransformation requiring
xenobiotics. Overall, the observed responses were similar to those reported for liver ceils in AFB-exposed
trout, suggesting that RTL-Wl cells are suitable for studying cytotoxic effects and malignant transform-
ation in vitro.
INTRODUCTION
Cell cultures provide useful means for studying cyto-
toxicity without involvement of the complex control
processes of the whole organism (Frazier, 1992;
Paganuzzi-Stammati et al., 1981; Watson, 1992).
Sentinel cells that could be readily and consistently
used for monitoring environmental toxicants, and
that maintain xenobiotic-metabolizing activity have
been sought for their applicability in toxicology
(Glatt et al., 1987). Usually, mammalian cell lines
have been used for monitoring the effects that
toxicants might have in those species and ultimately
these are correlated with effects in humans. In con-
trast, relatively few efforts have been aimed at inves-
tigating the effect toxicants that are particularly
abundant in aquatic environments have in the lower
vertebrates such as fish, and few fish cell lines have
*To whom correspondence should be addressed.
Abbreviations: AFB=aflatoxin B6 AFB2=aflatoxin B2;
AFB2~ = ariatoxin B2~; AFL = ariatoxicol; AFL-M =
aflatoxicol M 6 AFM = aflatoxin M~; AFP = aria-
toxin P6 AFQ = aflatoxin Q6 B[a]P = benzo[a]pyrene;
CHSE-214 = Chinook salmon embryo ceils; DMSO =
dimethyl sulfoxide; ECs0= effective concentration
required for 50% inhibition; FBS = foetal bovine serum;
SPE = solid phase extraction; TEM = transmission
electron microscopy; TLC = thin-layer chromatog-
raphy; RTG-2 = rainbow trout gonad cell line; RTL-
W1 = rainbow trout liver-Waterloo 1 cell line.
been developed or used for ecotoxicity testing in
these organisms (Babich and Borenfreund, 1987 and
1991).
Established cell lines are advantageous for routine
use in toxicology because of their immortality and
phenotype stability, but they have limited appli-
cations because of their poor capacity to metabolize
chemicals. Much effort has been spent in developing
culture systems with metabolically competent cells
such as hepatocytes (Kremers et al., 1990). Most
toxicology studies performed with fish cells also use
primary cultures of hepatocytes (Baksi and Frazier,
1990), as their functioning have been found to be
consistent with the role of the liver in situ (Moon
et al., 1985). But in general, primary cultures are
cumbersome to prepare, are short lived and produce
inconsistent results. Thus liver cell lines that maintain
metabolic capability have been sought.
Fish liver cell lines are few (Bols and Lee, 1991)
and most have been derived from malignant tumours,
which renders them unsuitable for correlating the
effects toxicants might have in normal tissues
as opposed to altered ceils. The RTL-Wl cell
line derived from rainbow trout liver, expressed
cytochrome P4501A1 activity, was sensitive to
benzo[a]pyrene, and possessed some attributes of the
normal organ of origin (Lee et al., 1993). Thus the
present study investigated whether the RTL-WI cell
line could be useful as a model fish sentinel cell line
317