Cognitive Impairment and Tramadol Dependence
Medhat M. Bassiony, MD, MSc, MBBCh, Usama M. Youssef, MD, MSc, MBBCh,
Mervat S. Hassan, MD, MSc, MBBCh, Ghada M. Salah El-Deen, MD, MSc, MBBCh,
Hayam El-gohari, MD, MSc, MBBCh, Mohamed Abdelghani, MD, MSc, MBBCh,
Ahmed Abdalla, MD, MSc, MBBCh, and Dalia H. Ibrahim, MD, MSc, MBBCh
Abstract:
Background and Objective: Cognitive impairment is one of the con-
sequences of substance abuse. Tramadol abuse is a public health problem
in Egypt. The objective of this study was to estimate the prevalence and
correlates of cognitive impairment among tramadol-abuse patients and
control subjects.
Methods: This study included 100 patients with tramadol abuse and 100
control subjects (matched for age, sex, and education) who were recruited
from Zagazig University Hospital, Egypt. Patients were divided into 2
groups: patients who used tramadol only (tramadol-alone group) and pa-
tients who used tramadol and other substances (polysubstance group).
The participants were interviewed using Montreal Cognitive Assessment
test and had urine screening for drugs.
Results: Twenty-four percent of the cases used tramadol alone, whereas the
remaining used tramadol and other substances, mainly cannabis (66%) and
benzodiazepines (27%). Tramadol-abuse patients were about 3 times more
likely to have cognitive impairment than control subjects (81% vs 28%).
Tramadol-alone patients were more than 2 times more likely to have cog-
nitive impairment than control subjects (67% vs 28%). Cognitive
impairment was significantly associated with polysubstance abuse. There
was no association between cognitive impairment and sociodemographic
or clinical factors.
Conclusions: Cognitive impairment occurs commonly among tramadol-
abuse patients. Memory impairment is the most common cognitive domain
to be affected. There is a significant association between cognitive impair-
ment and polysubstance abuse.
Key Words: cognitive impairment, Egypt, tramadol abuse
(J Clin Psychopharmacol 2017;37: 61–66)
T
he lifetime prevalence of substance use disorders (SUDs) in
Egypt was 9.6% according to a recent national survey.
1
Twenty percent to 40% of adults with SUD have used tramadol
in Egypt.
2–4
Eighty-three percent of Egyptian school students with
SUD have used tramadol at least once in their lifetime.
5
The main
source of the nonmedical use of tramadol is the black market
through illegal transaction mainly from China that made it easily
accessible and cheap.
6,7
Almost half of the tramadol-abuse pa-
tients had psychiatric comorbidity, and more than three-fourths
had cluster B personality disorders.
8
Depending on these reports,
the Egyptian Ministry of Health moved tramadol from Schedule
III to Schedule I (highly addictive).
9
Continued drug use causes cognitive deficits that aggravate
the difficulty of establishing sustained abstinence.
10
In fact, drug
addiction has been characterized as a disease of “pathological
learning” by several investigators.
10,11
Estimates regarding the
prevalence of cognitive impairment (CI) in SUD patients vary
widely and range from approximately 30% to 80%.
12
These defi-
cits may range from the relatively subtle temporary effects of can-
nabis use
13
to the moderate executive control deficits observed in
chronic cocaine users even following several months of absti-
nence.
14
Although these estimates do not include alcoholics who
develop permanent cognitive deficits such as Wernicke-Korsakoff
syndrome, they do include the enduring visuospatial information
processing deficits observed in nondemented persons with alcohol
use disorders.
15
Fishbain et al
16
reviewed 22 studies and reported
that patients on stable opioid doses had some impairment of
psychomotor abilities in 30% of the studies. Opioid-dependent
patients also experience cognitive function problems during opi-
oid substitution therapy.
17
Full opioid agonists (eg, morphine) have been shown to im-
pair some aspects of psychomotor and cognitive performance in
some studies.
18
Few studies have examined the effects of tramadol
on performance. Zacny
19
reported that neither tramadol (50 and
100 mg orally) nor morphine (25 mg orally) impaired psychomo-
tor performance relative to placebo in sporadic drug users. Two
studies
20,21
revealed that acute tramadol administration (50–400 mg
orally administered) did not impair performance in opioid-
dependent volunteers; however, interpretation is complicated
because participants were tested while in opioid withdrawal in
those studies. In addition, 2 studies evaluated the relationship be-
tween short-term (2–7 days) tramadol use and cognitive functions.
The first study
22
found worse cognitive performance in the mor-
phine group than in the tramadol group. The second study
23
reported comparable CI for the tramadol and fentanyl groups.
Although there are several reports in the literature on the ef-
fects of neurotransmitters agonist and antagonist in learning and
memory, the effect of tramadol as a drug with mechanism of ac-
tion affecting both mu receptor and serotonin, norepinephrine
and dopamine reuptake has not been well studied. All the previous
studies have investigated the acute effects of tramadol or other opi-
oids, but no studies looked at the relationship between long-term
tramadol use, abuse, or dependence and CI. Therefore, this study
was designed to evaluate and compare the effect of chronic use of
high doses of tramadol on cognitive functions.
The objectives of this study were:
1. to assess the prevalence and sociodemographic and clinical cor-
relates of CI in patients with tramadol abuse who seek treatment;
2. to compare CI between tramadol-abuse patients and control
subjects; and
3. to compare CI between those who use tramadol alone and
control subjects.
METHODS
Subjects
One hundred consecutive patients with a diagnosis of opi-
oid use disorder attributed to tramadol (OUD-T) according to
From the Psychiatry Department, Faculty of Medicine, Zagazig University,
Zagazig, Egypt.
Received May 29, 2016; accepted after revision October 18, 2016.
Reprints: Medhat M. Bassiony, MD, MSc, MBBCh, Psychiatry Department,
Faculty of Medicine, Zagazig University, Zagazig, Egypt
(e‐mail: mbassiony@hotmail.com).
Copyright © 2016 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. All rights reserved.
ISSN: 0271-0749
DOI: 10.1097/JCP.0000000000000617
ORIGINAL CONTRIBUTION
Journal of Clinical Psychopharmacology • Volume 37, Number 1, February 2017 www.psychopharmacology.com 61
Copyright © 2016 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. All rights reserved.