Critical evaluation of ex vivo restoration of carious equine maxillary
cheek teeth infundibulae following high-pressure gas and
micro-particle abrasion
P.M. Dixon *, D. Savill, A. Horbyl, R.J.M. Reardon, T. Liuti
The Royal Dick School of Veterinary Studies and The Roslin Institute, Easter Bush Veterinary Centre, The University of Edinburgh, Midlothian EH25 9RG,
Scotland, UK
ARTICLE INFO
Article history:
Accepted 4 April 2014
Keywords:
Equine dentistry
Cheek teeth
Infundibular caries
Restoration
ABSTRACT
Infundibular caries of the equine maxillary cheek teeth is an important disorder that can lead to dental
fracture or apical infection. Treatment by removing food debris and carious dental tissue from affected
infundibulae using high-pressure abrasion with aluminium hydroxide micro-particles, followed by filling
the cleaned defect with endodontic restorative materials is a recommended treatment. However, al-
though anecdotally considered a successful treatment option, there is currently no objective evidence
to support this claim.
Forty maxillary cheek teeth (CT) that contained 55 infundibulae with caries (mainly grade 2) were
extracted post-mortem from 21 adult horses. Five of the CT were sectioned prior to treatment to facili-
tate visual examination of the carious infundibulae. The remaining carious infundibulae were cleaned
using high-pressure abrasion with aluminium hydroxide particles and five CT were sectioned to assess
the efficacy of this cleaning process. The remaining 30 CT containing 39 carious infundibulae were then
filled with a composite restorative material. The efficacy of this restoration was assessed by computed
tomography imaging followed by direct visual examination after sectioning the teeth.
Only 46% (18/39) of restored infundibulae, all with shallow (mean 9.6 mm deep) defects, were fully
cleaned of food debris and carious material, and filled with restorative material to their full depth. Of
these 18, 11 had peripheral defects around the restoration, leaving just 18% (7/39) of restorations without
any gross defects. The remaining 54% (21/39) of infundibulae (mean depth of infundibular caries defect,
18.3 mm) still contained food debris and/or carious material in more apical locations, with infundibulae
with the deepest caries defects being the least effectively cleaned. The findings of this study indicate that
high-pressure micro-particle abrasion is only effective in cleaning food debris from shallow, carious CT
infundibulae and consequently, the majority of subsequent infundibular restorations are imperfect.
© 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Introduction
Equine maxillary cheek teeth (CT) contain two crescent-shaped
infundibulae, i.e. enamel invaginations that extend from the oc-
clusal surface for much of the length of the tooth. These infundibulae
should normally be filled with cementum, except for a small central
defect (Fig. 1), the site of the former vascular supply from the oc-
clusal aspect of the dental sac (Kilic et al., 1997; Dixon et al., 2011).
The fact that many horse and donkey CT infundibulae are incom-
pletely filled with normal cementum is considered a likely contrib-
utor to the development of caries (Becker, 1962; Baker, 1970; Kilic
et al., 1997; du Toit et al., 2008a, 2008b). The results of a recent an-
atomical study indicated that 88% of equine CT infundibulae had
areas of cemental developmental hypoplasia, or contained cemen-
tum that was discoloured, porous, or carious, with the Triadan 09
infundibulae being disproportionally affected by the most severe
cemental defects (Fitzgibbon et al., 2010). Similarly, a recent com-
puted tomography study by Windley et al. (2009) found lesions in
90% of all CT infundibulae.
A consequence of infundibular cemental defects is the impac-
tion of food deep into these spaces and the subsequent develop-
ment of caries. These lesions may remain confined to the infundibular
cementum (grade 1 according to the modified Honma grading system
[Dacre, 2005]; Fig. 1), extend to the underlying enamel (grade 2;
Fig. 2), involve enamel and dentine (grade 3; Fig. 3), or even result
in the loss of dental integrity (grade 4). Consequences of such ex-
tensions of caries include pulpar and thus apical infection of af-
fected CT (Dacre et al., 2008), or more commonly, mechanical
weakening of affected teeth. This may include coalescence of both
carious infundibulae and lead to midline sagittal fractures (Dacre
* Corresponding author. Tel.: +44 131 6506242.
E-mail address: p.m.dixon@ed.ac.uk (P.M. Dixon).
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.tvjl.2014.04.004
1090-0233/© 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
The Veterinary Journal 200 (2014) 368–374
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
The Veterinary Journal
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/tvjl