CMS (2007) 4:59–83
DOI 10.1007/s10287-006-0008-x
ORIGINAL PAPER
Combined discrete-event simulation and ant colony
optimisation approach for selecting optimal screening
policies for diabetic retinopathy
Sally C. Brailsford · Walter J. Gutjahr ·
Marion S. Rauner · Wolfgang Zeppelzauer
Published online: 15 August 2006
© Springer-Verlag 2006
Abstract In this paper we present the first application to a healthcare prob-
lem of discrete-event simulation (DES) embedded in an ant colony optimisation
(ACO) model. We are concerned with choosing optimal screening policies for
retinopathy, a sight-threatening complication of diabetes. The early signs of
retinopathy can be detected by screening before the patient is aware of symp-
toms, and blindness prevented by laser treatment. In this paper we describe
the methodology used to combine the purpose-written DES model with the
ACO algorithm. We simulate the effects of different screening strategies on a
population of diabetic patients, and compare them in terms of two objective
functions: Min C/E, cost-effectiveness (minimum incremental cost per year of
sight saved, compared with a no-screening baseline) and Max E, maximum
effectiveness (years of sight saved). We describe how ACO is used to optimise
these two objectives, and discuss the issues involved in optimising stochastic
variables. We present results for a range of different assumptions and scenarios
about the format of screening programmes, using realistic data, and make policy
recommendations on the basis of our findings.
Keywords Screening for diabetic retinopathy · Discrete event simulation ·
Ant colony optimisation · Cost-effectiveness analysis · Decision-support system
S. C. Brailsford (B )
School of Management, University of Southampton, Southampton S017 1BJ, UK
e-mail: s.c.brailsford@soton.ac.uk
W. J. Gutjahr
Department of Statistics and Decision Support Systems, University of Vienna,
Universitaetsstraße 5/9, 1010 Vienna, Austria
e-mail: walter.gutjahr@univie.ac.at
M. S. Rauner · W. Zeppelzauer
University of Vienna, School of Business and Economics,
Bruenner Str. 72, 1210 Vienna, Austria
e-mail: marion.rauner@univie.ac.at