Casual Cynics or Disillusioned Democrats?
Political Alienation in Japan
Ikuo Kabashima
Faculty of Law, University of Tokyo
Jonathan Marshall
Department of Political Science, University of California, Berkeley
Takayoshi Uekami and Dae-Song Hyun
Faculty of Law, University of Tokyo
This paper examines the structure of political alienation among Japanese eligible voters,
using data from the first, second, fifth, and sixth waves of the seven-wave Japanese Electoral
Survey II (JES II). Political alienation can be expressed as comprising two dimensions,
political trust and civic-mindedness. Males and people with more years of schooling are
more allegiant in general; that is, they are both more trusting and more civic-minded.
Evaluations of cabinet performance and support for democratic mechanisms are strongly
related to political trust and civic-mindedness. Supporters of the Liberal Democratic Party
(LDP) are no more civic-minded than average but are more trusting politically, whereas
Japan Communist Party supporters are more civic-minded but a good deal less politically
trusting than average. Independents are below the overall average on both the political trust
and civic-mindedness dimensions. Even though party support is unstable, Japan’s political
system will not lose its stability as long as LDP supporters and independents constitute the
majority of Japan’s electorate. The advent of a new party capable of providing an alternative
to the LDP is important to the future of Japanese democracy.
KEY WORDS: political alienation, Japan, political trust, political efficacy, party identification.
Japanese voters have long expressed dissatisfaction with politics. Generally
low levels of trust in government and lack of a sense of effectiveness among
Japanese voters hardly come as a surprise to specialists in Japanese politics or to
the reading public. Closer analysis of Japanese voters’ sense of alienation supports
existing explanations developed for political alienation in a different national
Political Psychology, Vol. 21, No. 4, 2000
779
0162-895X © 2000 International Society of Political Psychology
Published by Blackwell Publishers, 350 Main Street, Malden, MA 02148, USA, and 108 Cowley Road, Oxford, OX4 1JF, UK.