Strategic Management of Worker
Health, Safety, and
Environmental Issues in Mexico's
Maquiladora Industry*
Mark C. Butler and Mary B. Teagarden
Conflict arising from differences in business practices, standards, values, and norms
guiding behavior are inherent in international business. These conflicts are evident in
Mexico's maquiladora industry, particularly relating to issues of worker health, safety,
and environment. This article extends a model of conflict management; illustnites the
model's dimensions with case study examples; discusses strategic human resource man-
agement implications of the model's various outcomes; offers recommendations for manag-
ing worker health, safety, and environment issues; and identifies directions for future
research. © 1993 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
INTRODUCTION
Mexico is a country ripe for worker health, safety, and environmental
abuse. Economically, the country is striving aggressively to attract in-
vestment and create jobs. Geographically, it shares a 2000-mile border
with the United States, whose more stringent pollution regulations
make Mexico a tempting destination for factories running away from
environmental restrictions; for manufacturers looking for a cheap, albeit
illegal, toxic waste dump; and whose strict worker health and safety
regulations "encourage" firms to flee to Mexico to exploit less rigorous
enforcement. Against these forces are, for example, barely 100 industrial
pollution inspectors and a 4-year-old law covering emissions of 12,000
substances—:versus the 75,000 regulated in the United States. To com-
pound the legal and inspection issues, there is the classic enforcement
problem that comes with underpaid civil servants and wealthy violators:
bribery. Final approval of the impending North American Free Trade
An earlier version of this manuscript received the Minerva Education Insti-
tute Irwin/Proctor & Gamble Award for Research Contributions to Worker
Health, Safety and Environment at the 1992 National Academy of Management
Meeting, Las Vegas, Nevada.
Human Resource Management, Winter 1993, Vol. 32, Number 4, Pp. 479-503
© 1993 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc. CCC 0090-4848/93/040479-25