RESEARCH ARTICLE
195 |
AUTHORS
Elizabeth Simpson, MD,
1
Neera K. Goyal, MD,
MSHP,
2
Niramol Dhepyasuwan, MEd,
3
Valerie
J. Flaherman, MD, MPH,
4
Esther K. Chung,
MD, MPH,
5
Isabelle Von Kohorn, MD, PhD,
6
Anthony Burgos, MD,
7
James Taylor, MD
8
1
University of Missouri–Kansas City School of
Medicine, Children’s Mercy Hospital Kansas City,
Missouri;
2
Division of Neonatology and Division of Hospital
Medicine, Cincinnati Children’s Hospital Medical
Center, Cincinnati, Ohio;
3
Academic Pediatric Association, McLean, Virginia;
4
University of California at San Francisco, San
Francisco, California;
5
Nemours and Jefferson Medical College,
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania;
6
Holy Cross Health, Silver Spring, Maryland;
7
Well Newborn Care, Kaiser Permanente, Downey,
California; and
8
Department of Pediatrics, University of Washington,
Seattle, and Newborn Nursery, University of
Washington Medical Center, Seattle, Washington
KEY WORDS
academic medical centers, Delphi technique,
infant, newborn, nursery
ABBREVIATIONS
AAP: American Academy of Pediatrics
BORN: Better Outcomes through Research for
Newborns
GBS: group B streptococcus
PROS: Pediatric Research in Office Settings
www.hospitalpediatrics.org
doi:10.1542/hpeds.2014-0003
Address correspondence to Elizabeth Simpson,
MD, General Pediatrics/Broadway Clinics, 2401
Gillham Rd, Kansas City, MO 64108. E-mail:
easimpson@cmh.edu
HOSPITAL PEDIATRICS (ISSN Numbers: Print,
2154 - 1663; Online, 2154 - 1671).
Copyright © 2014 by the American Academy of
Pediatrics
In the United States, birth newborn hospitalizations outnumber those for all other
pediatric age groups combined at a ratio of ∼3 to 1.
1
More than 90% of all new-
borns are cared for in routine birth hospital settings outside of NICUs.
2,3
In a
2004 policy statement, the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) stated that
routine newborn hospital care is essential for a safe, healthy transition home.
4
Outcomes related to the newborn hospitalization such as breastfeeding rates
and readmission increasingly represent areas for quality measurement in pediat-
ric hospital care. Moreover, national trends, such as the rise in the late preterm
birth rate and the more recent increase in the incidence of neonatal abstinence
syndrome, underscore the importance of effective approaches to routine new-
born hospital care to prevent adverse outcomes. Although routine newborn care
represents such a large proportion of all pediatric hospital care, few specific rou-
tine newborn interventions have been rigorously evaluated. In the absence of a
good evidence base, clinicians caring for newborns may rely on varying historical
practices and individual clinical judgment. To develop a more robust and useful
Prioritizing a Research Agenda: A Delphi
Study of the Better Outcomes Through
Research for Newborns (BORN) Network
(Continued on last page)
abstract
BACKGROUND: There is a paucity of evidence to guide clinical management
for term and late preterm newborns. The Better Outcomes through Research
for Newborns (BORN) network is a national collaborative of clinicians formed to
increase the evidence-base for well newborn care.
OBJECTIVE: To develop a consensus-based, prioritized research agenda for
well newborn care.
DESIGN: A two-round modified Delphi survey of BORN members was
conducted. Round 1 was an open-ended survey soliciting 5 clinical questions
identified as important and under-researched. Using qualitative methods, 20
most common themes were extracted and transformed into research questions.
Round 2 survey respondents ranked the top 20 questions using a 5- point Likert
scale and a quantitative analysis was conducted.
RESULTS: Round 1 survey generated 439 unique research questions that fell
into 57 themes. In the Round 2 survey, the highest rated questions were: 1) At
what weight-loss percentage is it medically necessary to formula supplement
a breastfeeding infant? 2) What is the optimal management of infants with
neonatal abstinence syndrome? 3) How and when should we initiate a workup
for sepsis, and how should these newborns be managed?
CONCLUSIONS: Research priorities of clinicians include criteria for medically
indicated formula supplementation of the breastfed newborn, management of
neonatal abstinence syndrome and management of newborns at-risk for sepsis.