Abstract
We propose a novel framework that combines probabilistic
transmission with Latin Squares characteristics to tune
channel access, meeting various demands in network
performance (Energy vs. Delay). The proposed technique is
decentralized, scalable, and has low overhead. We develop an
analytical model to estimate the network performance and
validate the benefits of the proposed framework via
simulation-based experiments.
Keywords: adaptable access, sensor network, network
performance
I. INTRODUCTION
mart sensor networks naturally apply to a broad range of
applications with different requirements to network
performance. One of the major requirements is proper energy
utilization in Wireless Sensor Networks (WSN) [5] [9]. At the
same time, minimizing sensor query response time is equally
crucial in mission-critical sensor networks. In general, the
time/energy trade-offs involve energy and time gains/losses
associated with specific channel access methods. In this paper
we consider the network performance issue in WSNs from a
different perspective. Instead of designing an explicit
communication protocol to meet certain objectives, we
propose tuning the channel access mechanism in an adaptable
way to handle different application requirements.
In this paper we emphasize performance tuning with
objectives to minimize Energy consumption and Delay.
Maintaining acceptable query response time and high energy
efficiency is a Multi-objective Optimization Problem (MOP)
[2]. In general, MOP aims at minimizing the values of several
objective functions f1 … fn under a given set of constraints. In
most cases it is unlikely that different objectives would be
optimized by the same choice of parameters (i.e., vectors). To
choose between different vectors of the optimization
objectives, an optimizer utilizes the concept of Pareto
optimality [2]. Informally, an objective vector is said to be
Pareto optimal if all other feasible vectors in the objective
space have a higher value for at least one of the objective
functions, or else have the same value for all objectives.
Typically, there is more than one Pareto optimal vector
(Pareto points) reflecting the trade-offs between different
objectives. Our adaptable transmission approach follows the
concept of Pareto optimality while considering the tradeoffs
between energy and delay objectives.
We propose a novel access scheme, Adaptable Probabilistic
Transmission framework (APT). APT is an extension of
Cyclic Probabilistic Transmission protocol (CPT) [3] that
performs data transmissions based on predefined probabilities.
In a manner similar to CPT, APT maintains a Transmission
Probability Matrix (TPM), each cell of which holds a
probability of data transmission of a sensor within a given
time slot. The TPM specifies one “network transmission
cycle” where every sensor knows its own transmission
probabilities in fixed time slots and repetitively uses the TPM
for distributed data transmissions. In addition, location
information is used to improve channel access. Similar to the
Grid-based Latin Squares Scheduling Access Protocol
(GLASS) [11], sensors divide the monitoring area into a
virtual grid. Then each sensor associates itself with one virtual
grid cell or sector using geographical data. This design allows
neighboring sensors to maintain spatial and temporal
separation between potentially colliding packets while keeping
channel access scalable. Note that APT assumes that each
node in a WSN is aware of its geographic location
1
. While
location-based approaches have been adopted in routing
mechanisms [1], to the best of our knowledge they are rarely
utilized for optimizing channel access. Finally, APT uses the
Latin Squares characteristics (LS) [4] to tune the probabilities
in the TPMs of sensors enabling trade-offs between our
optimization objectives. We demonstrate feasibility of our
technique analytically and using simulations. The analytical
model captures the characteristics of the WSN with APT while
the simulation study validates the analysis and the
performance in different networking environments. In
particular, the simulation results show that the APT control
overhead cost is very low since APT is based only on local
sensor processing. The organization of this paper is as follows:
in Section II we discuss related work on channel access of
WSNs. In Section III we introduce the new APT framework.
In Section IV we briefly summarize the APT analysis and in
Section V we test its feasibility via simulations. Finally, in
Section VI we offer our conclusion.
II. RELATED WORK
Channel access in WSNs can be classified into scheduling-
based and random-based access categories. Random-based
1
We note that using global positioning system (GPS) is not always possible in WSNs
because of energy and location precision constraints. WSNs commonly utilize ad hoc
localization methods based on nodes, calculating their coordinates using special beacon
nodes whose positions are known. Further consideration of this subject is beyond of the
scope of this paper.
Adaptable Probabilistic Transmission Framework for Wireless Sensor Networks
Chih-Kuang Lin Vladimir Zadorozhny and Prashant Krishnamurthy
Q2S, NTNU, Norway University of Pittsburgh, USA
chih@q2s.ntnu.no {vladimir, prashant}@sis.pitt.edu
S
2009 Third International Conference on Sensor Technologies and Applications
978-0-7695-3669-9/09 $25.00 © 2009 IEEE
DOI 10.1109/SENSORCOMM.2009.109
676