978-1-61284-848-8/11/$26.00 ©2011 IEEE
Fusion of ALOS and QuickBird Imagery for
Mangrove Analysis
A Case Study in Beilun Estuary, Vietnam
Jia Hu, Minhe Ji*
Key Lab of Geographic Information Science,
Ministry of Education and East China Normal University
Shanghai, P.R.China
mhji@geo.ecnu.edu.cn
Abstract—This study compared four image fusion techniques for
mangrove studies in the Beilun estuary, Vietnam. The fused
image was generated from an ALOS multi-spectral image scene
and a Quickbird panchromatic image scene. Four quantitative
indices (i.e. mean, standard deviation, entropy, and correlation
coefficient) were used to compare and evaluate the results of the
fusion methods. Variation of fusion effects was observed among
different methods. In addition, fused images were used to identify
mangrove biomass levels via spectral mixture analysis. The
fusion results are not quite very well from a series of evaluations,
two possible explanations of the failure results present in the
conclusion, which provide the reference for the relevant research.
Keyword-image fusion; mangrove biomass; spectral mixture
analysis
I. INTRODUCTION
Wetlands are considered the most biologically diverse of all
ecosystems [1]. Mangroves as a primary plant life are both an
important coastal wetland resource and one of the most highly
productive seashore ecosystems around the world [2]. Due to
its desirable functions for abundant primary production, carbon
storage, and ecological buffering between human settlements
and the marine ecosystem, mangrove’s inventory and
monitoring are of utmost importance [3]. Recent research even
deemed that mangroves as one of the best geo-indicators in
global coastal change research and excellent procedures to
detect and quantify coastal modifications [4].
Because of their broad scientific and economic, and even
aesthetic and ethical values [5], mangrove wetlands deserve a
great deal of attention in their monitoring and management.
Remote sensing technology has been broadly used for forestry
studies [6], but the current practice is still short of methods to
extract detailed information about mangrove species and
biomass [7]. Many studies have revealed that due to the high
spectral similarity among different mangrove species, merely
increasing the spatial resolution of imagery might have led to a
wrong direction. A widely recognized observation is that
spectral resolution is the true determinant for discrimination at
species level.
While it is still not viable to collect hyperspectral data for
any specific study area nowadays, the proliferation of different
sensor types and platforms provides a great opportunity to
increase spectral dimensions through image fusion. It is the aim
of image fusion to integrate image data recorded at different
resolutions and/or by different sensors to obtain more ground
information than otherwise derived from a single image alone.
This study evaluated four pixel-level image fusion methods
for the purpose of improving the identification of mangrove
species in Beilun Estuary, Vietnam. The fusions involved the
multispectral data from AVNIR-2 of the Advanced Land
Observing Satellite (ALOS) and the panchromatic data from
QuickBird. Four conventional quantitative indices were used to
assess and compare the fusion results, including mean, standard
deviation, entropy, and correlation coefficient. Since it was
difficult to judge the quality of each fusion outcome simply
based on the indices, the fused images were further evaluated
through the assessment of mangrove biomass levels results
from spectral mixture analyses (SMA). The summary statistics
provided some useful insight into the feasibility of image
fusion for mangrove analysis.
II. METHODOLOGY
A. HSV Transformation
HSV is a cylindrical-coordinate color system comprised of
three color elements: hue, saturation, and value. It is usually
constructed by transformation from the RGB color space [9,
10]. Since this transformation is nonlinear and reversible, it is
widely used for fusing images of different spatial resolutions.
The specific fusion procedure for this study is follows. An
HSV transform was first performed to convert multispectral
data from the RGB color space to the HSV color space. Then
the transformed data in the hue and saturation bands was
resampled to the resolution of the panchromatic data. In the
final step, a reverse transform was performed to convert data
from HSV space back to RGB, with the value-band data being
replaced by the panchromatic data [11].
Limitations have been reported for use of HSV transform in
image fusion. This approach is known to work well for a
moderate resolution ratio (1:4) and less reliable for ratios
greater than 1:20. It is also noted that fusion by HSV transform
only works for multispectral imagery consisting of three bands,
as it is limited by the RGB channels for transformation.
Supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (No.
40671074).