Journal of Communication, September 2002
522
Verbal and Nonverbal Communication:
Distinguishing Symbolic, Spontaneous,
and Pseudo-Spontaneous Nonverbal
Behavior
By Ross Buck and C. Arthur VanLear
Verbal and nonverbal communication are seen in terms of interacting streams of
spontaneous and symbolic communication, and posed “pseudo-spontaneous” dis-
plays. Spontaneous communication is defined as the nonintentional communica-
tion of motivational-emotional states based upon biologically shared
nonpropositional signal systems, with information transmitted via displays. Sym-
bolic communication is the intentional communication, using learned, socially
shared signal systems, of propositional information transmitted via symbols. Pseudo-
spontaneous communication involves the intentional and strategic manipulation
of displays. An original meta-analysis demonstrates that, like verbal symbolic com-
munication, nonverbal analogic (pantomimic) communication is related to left
hemisphere cerebral processing. In contrast, spontaneous communication is re-
lated to the right hemisphere.
A general theory of communication should account for the natural biologically
based aspects of communication as well as its learned and symbolically structured
aspects. Further, such a general theory should include a feedback process—expla-
nations of message production alone or message reception alone, although po-
tentially useful, are incomplete. A corollary of these two criteria is that a general
theory of communication should account for the coevolution of symbolic and
nonsymbolic feedback processes and their integration into systems of communi-
cation characteristic of the human species. Whereas the explication of such a
general theory is beyond the scope of this article, developmental interactionist
theory (Buck, 1984, 1989, 1994) does aim to offer such an integrated view. The
current article poses how developmental interactionist theory deals with the topic
of this special issue of Journal of Communication—the relationship between ver-
bal and nonverbal communication.
Ross Buck (PhD, University of Pittsburgh) is a professor of communication sciences and psychology
at the University of Connecticut, where C. Arthur VanLear (PhD, University of Utah) is an associate
professor of communication sciences.
Copyright © 2002 International Communication Association