In situ Measurement of Cadaveric Soft Tissue Mechanical Properties and
Fulcrum Forces for Use in Physics-Based Surgical Simulation
Yi-Je Lim
∗
Suvranu De
†
Daniel B. Jones
‡
Tejinder P. Singh
°
Department of
Mechanical,
Aerospace and
Nuclear Engineering,
Rensselaer
Polytechnic Institute
Department of
Mechanical,
Aerospace and
Nuclear Engineering,
Rensselaer
Polytechnic Institute
Department of
Surgery,
Beth Israel Deaconess
Medical Center
Department of
Surgery,
Albany Medical
College
ABSTRACT
Development of a realistic surgery simulator that delivers
high fidelity visual and haptic feedback, based on the
physics of deformable objects, requires the use of empirical
data on the behavior of soft tissues when subjected to
external loads. Measurements on live human patients
present significant risks, thus making the use of cadavers a
logical alternative. Cadavers are widely used in present day
surgical training, are relatively easy to procure through
excellent donor programs and have the right anatomy,
which makes them better candidates for training than the
porcine model. To investigate the static and dynamic
properties of soft tissue, we have developed a high
precision tactile stimulator by modifying an exisitng haptic
interface device, the Phantom, and used it to record the
force-displacement behavior of intra-abdominal organs of
fresh human cadavers at the US Surgical in Connecticut
and Albany Medical College. Another paraemeter of great
practical significace, but mostly overlooked in the
literature, is the fulcrum force at the point of entry of the
trocar into the abdomen. The length of the surgical tools,
coupled with a thick abdominal wall of overweight or
obese patients, tend to produce torques at the wrist of the
surgeon which are often large enough to mask any haptic
sensation from the organs being operated on. To ascertain
the true role of haptics in endoscopic surgery one needs to
measure these fulcrum forces. In this paper we discuss
techniques and some preliminary results in this direction.
Keywords: soft tissue, biomechanical properties, human
cadaver, indentation experiment, surgical simulation
*
limy@rpi.edu
†
des@rpi.edu
‡
djones1@bidmc.harvard.edu
°
SinghT@mail.amc.edu
I. INTRODUCTION
To provide realistic visual and haptic feedback to the
user, physics-based computational techniques, such as the
finite element method [1-5] or meshfree methods [6] have
been advocated. These techniques are based on numerically
solving partial differential equations that govern the
physical behavior of soft tissues, subject to boundary
and/or initial conditions. While the differential equations
represent conservation of momentum, they contain a few
coefficients, known as the constitutive tensor, which must
be determined experimentally. For instance, in linear
elasticity, the stress (
ij
σ ) and strain (
kl
ε ) tensors are
related by the rank four elasticity tensor (
ijkl
C ) through the
Hookean relationship
{, , , } {1, 2, 3}
ij ijkl kl
C ijkl σ ε = ∈ (1)
For a homogeneous, isotropic material the elasticity tensor
has just two independent constants (Young’s modulus, E,
and Poison’s ratio, ν) [7], which must be empirically
determined. Notice that only a few well-conceived
experiments are necessary to determine these constants, in
contrast to, for example, spring-mass models, where
hundreds of thousands of stiffness values have to be
assigned using elaborate curve fitting techniques [8]
sometimes using neural networks.
Measurement of soft tissue properties is a well-
established research area [9,10]. However, the major
challenge in this field is that soft tissues exhibit
complicated mechanical behavior including nonlinear,
inhomogeneous, anisotropic, and rate dependent response.
For surgical simulation, ideally it is necessary to
measure, and then model the in vivo mechanical response
of the soft tissues operated on. However, the current efforts
are either aimed at obtaining ex vivo properties [9,11],
which are grossly different from in vivo conditions [12,13],
or utilizing animal models such as the porcine model
[12,13] which have fundamental differences in anatomy
and tissue consistency compared to humans. The use of
fresh human cadavers is a risk-free alternative to live
human experiments, and is pursued in this paper. Cadavers
259
Symposium on Haptic Interfaces for
Virtual Environment and Teleoperator Systems 2006
March 25 - 26, Alexandria, Virginia, USA
1-4244-0226-3/06/$20.00 ©2006 IEEE