International Journal of Sports Science 2014, 4(4): 136-141
DOI: 10.5923/j.sports.20140404.03
A Primary School-based Educational Program to Improve
Fall Skills; Process Evaluation Alongside a Cluster
Randomized Controlled Trial
Joske Nauta
1
, Lize Adriaensens
2
, Karin Klein Wolt
2
, Willem Van Mechelen
1
, Evert Verhagen
1,*
1
Department of Public & Occupational Health, EMGO Institute for Health and Care Research, VU University Medical Center,
Amsterdam, 1081 BT, The Netherlands
2
Consumer Safety Institute, Amsterdam, 1059 GK, The Netherlands
Abstract In this study, the process evaluation of an educational program to improve fall skills in primary school age
children was conducted alongside a cluster randomized controlled trial using the RE-AIM framework. Thirty-three schools
participated in a cluster-randomized controlled trial. Seventeen schools were randomly allocated to the intervention group.
Injuries were registered during a school year. Fall skills were assessed using self-reports and a fall skills test. And
questionnaires were used to evaluate experiences of both children and teachers with the educational program. All children
participating in physical education lessons were reached. The program was effective in increasing self-perceived fall–skills
and the score on a fall-skills test (0.94 points), but the change in fall-related injury rates did not reach significance.
Fourteen percent of invited schools was willing to Adopt the educational program. And although participating teachers
were positive about the educational program, 89% failed to implement the exercises as intended. Lastly, 54% of the
teachers intended to maintain the educational program in their regular teaching routine. Given that many teachers failed to
implement the intervention as intended, it is promising that fall skills in children did significantly improve after the
intervention. The reason why this did not result in corresponding decrease in fall related injury risk remains unclear.
Adjusting the educational program to better fit the needs of teachers potentially increases adoption of the program which
could result in a more effective educational injury prevention program.
Keywords Educational program, Fall-related injury prevention, Implementation, Primary school-based, Process
evaluation
1. Introduction
Primary schools are considered a key intervention context
through which Physical Activity (PA) levels can be
increased in order to prevent childhood obesity and
sedentary behavior related diseases [1]. Through sports,
Physical Education (PE) and play, children of all ages are
encouraged to participate in PA. Yet the risk of related injury
is often neglected in these efforts to promote daily PA.
In children, PA promotion is usually focused on leisure
time PA. Although the number of injuries expressed per
1,000 hours of physical activity associated with these
activities is lower than for organized PA (i.e. PE and sports),
absolute numbers as well as costs associated with these
injuries are significantly higher [2, 3]. Also, leisure time PA
is related to a relatively large number of forearm fractures
* Corresponding author:
e.verhagen@vumc.nl (Evert Verhagen)
Published online at http://journal.sapub.org/sports
Copyright © 2014 Scientific & Academic Publishing. All Rights Reserved
[3]. Overall forearm fractures account for up to one third of
childhood fractures [4], and about 40% to 50% of children
sustain at least one fracture during childhood5. Also given a
steady increase in the incidence of forearm fractures over the
last 30 years [4], it is evident that preventive measures are
warranted.
Currently, little is known about the mechanisms
underlying the observed increase in forearm fractures.
Regarding the injury mechanism, it has been described that
80% of forearm fractures occur after a fall [6]. Since falling
is an inescapable part of a child’s daily play and PA, it is
unlikely that falls can be completely avoided. The injury
resulting from a fall could, however, be reduced when
children are trained to properly react when falling. Martial
arts falling techniques have, for example, shown to decrease
forearm ground reaction forces [7, 8] thereby potentially
reducing the risk of sustaining a forearm fracture [7]. In the
Netherlands, an educational program, consisting of exercises
based on martial arts techniques, was developed to improve
fall skills in children. In this study, the process of
implementation was evaluated.