Domestic Politics and Prospect Theory
in International Conflict: Explaining
Japan’s War Decision in the 1904 Russo-
Japanese War
Steven B. Rothman, Ritsumeikan Asia Paciic University
Abstract
his project explains the Japanese decision for war against Russia in 1904 by applying
theories of war involving the democratic process, the domestic and government interests,
and prospect theory. he project demonstrates the limits of psychological variables to
analyze or explain international decisions due to the political complexity and domestic
and global context of decision-making. In particular, the project uses economic framing
to proxy a gains domain and security frames to proxy the losses domain. Risk sensitivities
and preference ordering of the domestic interests (military and common business persons)
are consistent with prospect theory, while the political connections between domestic
constituents and decision-makers provide an intervening inluence on the decision for war.
he result suggests careful use of prospect theory and the importance of factors in addition
to psychological ones when applied to international politics.
Keywords: decision-making, international conlict, prospect theory, Russo-Japanese War
Introduction
his project demonstrates the importance of careful use of cognitive decision theories to
illuminate international relations decisions. Despite scholars’ widespread and increasing
use of psychological variables to explain international afairs, the complexity and context
of international and other intervening conditions make psychological variables diicult
to fully utilize in the international context. he essay examines the inluence of framing
from diferent inluential actors in the Japanese decision to begin war with Russia. he
essay shows that contextual variables interfere with cognitive decision biases and frames,
thus reducing the inluence of psychological factors at the international level of decision-
making.
Asia Paciic World 2(2), Autumn 2011: 66–84 © Asia Paciic World
doi:10.3167/apw.2011020206