Neutron and /γ Radiolysis of Water up to Supercritical Conditions. 1. /γ Yields for H
2
,
H
•
Atom, and Hydrated Electron
Dorota Janik, Ireneusz Janik, and David M. Bartels*
Radiation Laboratory, UniVersity of Notre Dame, Notre Dame, Indiana 46556
ReceiVed: March 3, 2007; In Final Form: June 7, 2007
Yields for H
2
,H
•
atom, and hydrated electron production in /γ radiolysis of water have been measured from
room temperature up to 400 °C on a 250 bar isobar, and also as a function of pressure (density) at 380 and
400 °C. Radiolysis was carried out using a beam of 2-3 MeV electrons from a van de Graaff accelerator,
and detection was by mass spectrometer analysis of gases sparged from the irradiated water. N
2
O was used
as a specific scavenger for hydrated electrons giving N
2
as product. Ethanol-d
6
was used to scavenge H
•
atoms, giving HD as a stable product. It is found that the hydrated electron yield decreases and the H
•
atom
yield increases dramatically at lower densities in supercritical water, and the overall escape yield increases.
The yield of molecular H
2
increases with temperature and does not tend toward zero at low density, indicating
that it is formed promptly rather than in spur recombination. A minimum in both the radical and H
2
yields
is observed around 0.4 kg/dm
3
density in supercritical water.
I. Introduction
Commercial nuclear reactors essentially provide a source of
heat used to drive a “heat engine” (turbine) to create electricity.
A fundamental result of Thermodynamics shows that the higher
the temperature at which any heat engine is operated, the greater
its efficiency. Consequently, one obvious way to increase the
operating efficiency and profitability for future nuclear power
plants is to heat the water of the primary cooling loop to higher
temperatures. Current pressurized water reactors run at roughly
300 °C and 100 atm pressure.
1
Designs under consideration
would operate at 500 °C and 250 atm,
2-6
i.e., well beyond the
critical point of water. This would improve the thermodynamic
efficiency by about 30% and allow considerable reduction in
cost. A major unanswered question has been, what changes
occur in the radiation-induced chemistry in water as the
temperature and pressure are raised beyond the critical point,
and what do these imply for the limiting corrosion processes in
the materials of the primary cooling loop?
Direct measurement of the chemistry in reactor cores is
extremely difficult. The extreme conditions of high temperature,
pressure, and radiation fields are not compatible with normal
chemical instrumentation. There are also problems of access to
fuel channels in the reactor core. For these reasons, all reaction
vendors and many operators have extensively used theoretical
calculations and chemical models to simulate the detailed
radiation chemistry of the water in the core and the consequences
for materials.
7,8
The results of these model calculations can be
no more accurate than the fundamental information fed into
them, and serious discrepancies remain between model calcula-
tions and reactor experiments.
8,9
The problem of modeling a
supercritical-water-cooled reactor is even more daunting. A
number of studies have been published in the last several years
with the aim of providing the necessary fundamental information
needed to model radiation chemistry in supercritical water.
10-23
Both reaction rates and radiation yields (G-values) for the
primary free radicals
•
OH, H
•
, and e
aq
-
are required, as well as
for the recombination products H
2
and H
2
O
2
. Moreover, in
reactor cores radiation is deposited both via γ radiation and
energetic neutrons;
24
this paper represents the first in a series
that will report G values from both /γ radiation and neutrons
using the same detection methodology.
To transfer the information to other systems for modeling
studies, it is very important to know precisely the temperature
and pressure of the fluid under irradiation. This is much easier
to achieve with a flowing system than with sealed samples. For
neutron experiments a high-temperature flow system was
constructed for a small nuclear reactor at the University of
Wisconsin, as will be described in subsequent papers. As a
source of low-LET radiation for high-temperature experiments,
we have found it very convenient to use an electron beam from
a 3 MeV van de Graaff accelerator. The choice of detection
method and scavengers is dictated by the characteristics of the
reactor. The simplest method with sufficiently high sensitivity,
reliability, and versatility is the detection of stable gas products
produced by the radiation
25
using a mass spectrometer.
In the following section we describe in some detail the
detection technique that is common to both experiments. The
scavenging experiments and results are then described, and in
the Discussion we compare these results with others in the
literature.
II. Experimental Section
The -radiolysis experiments were performed at the Notre
Dame Radiation Laboratory using a custom-made supercritical
water (SCW) irradiation block and 2.5 MeV electrons from a
3.0 MeV van de Graaff (VdG) accelerator. The apparatus
consisted of sample reservoirs and pumps, a high pressure/
temperature irradiation flowtube, and ambient pressure/temper-
ature analysis setup with a directly coupled mass spectrometer
(Figure 1).
Two glass water reservoirs with copper or stainless steel
connection lines under atmospheric pressure were used to supply
* To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail: bartels@
hertz.rad.nd.edu. Phone (574) 631-5561. Fax: (574) 631-8068.
7777 J. Phys. Chem. A 2007, 111, 7777-7786
10.1021/jp071751r CCC: $37.00 © 2007 American Chemical Society
Published on Web 07/24/2007