Development and Psychometric Evaluation of the Revised Protective
Behavioral Strategies Scale
Michael B. Madson, Randolph C. Arnau, and Sasha J. Lambert
The University of Southern Mississippi
Psychometrically sound measures of the use of protective behavioral strategies are only in a development
stage at this point. One such measure, the Protective Behavioral Strategies Scale (PBSS), has shown
particular promise in this area. This study aimed to build on the PBSS by (a) evaluating revisions to the
measure intended to yield more reliable scores from the serious harm reduction (SHR) subscale and (b)
evaluating the factor structure of the revised measure and the stability of the factor structure across White
non-Hispanics and African Americans and between women and men using multigroup confirmatory
factor analysis. Three additional items were added to the SHR subscale, which improved its functioning.
A 2-factor model best fit the data, and the factor structure of the measure was invariant across White
non-Hispanic and African American men and women. Suggestions for further refinement of the measure
and future research are provided.
Keywords: college alcohol abuse, protective strategies, assessment
A major concern on university campuses is the abuse of alcohol
among college students. It is estimated that as many as 69% of
college students drank alcohol in the past month, and 45% drank
enough to get drunk (Johnston, O’Malley, Bachman, & Schulen-
berg, 2009). These numbers increase to 82% and 67% when
looking at alcohol use in the past year (Johnston et al., 2009).
While rates of heavy episodic drinking have remained relatively
stable since 1993, negative alcohol-related consequences have
significantly increased since that time (Hingson, Zha, & Weitz-
man, 2009). Researchers, administrators, and prevention special-
ists are increasingly recognizing the importance of student use of
protective behavioral strategies to reduce alcohol consumption and
negative consequences (Martens, Taylor, Damann, Page, Mowry,
& Cimini, 2004).
Protective Behavioral Strategies
Protective behavioral strategies (PBS) are tactics that can be
used while drinking alcohol to decrease negative alcohol-related
consequences and possibly limit alcohol consumption (Martens et
al., 2004). Some examples of PBS include determining not to
exceed a certain number of drinks, alternating between alcoholic
and nonalcoholic drinks, stopping drinking at a predetermined
time, avoiding drinking games, and using a designated driver
(Martens, Pedersen, LaBrie, Ferrier, & Cimini, 2007). PBS are of
increasing interest in relation to college student drinking because
an inverse relationship between PBS and negative alcohol-related
consequences has been well documented in the literature (Araas &
Adams, 2008; Benton et al., 2004; Howard, Griffin, Boekeloo,
Lake, & Bellows, 2007; Martens et al., 2004). However, limita-
tions of these studies suggest that the results be interpreted with
caution. Further, until the development of the Protective Behavior
Strategy Scale (Martens et al., 2005), PBS use was often qualita-
tively assessed.
Protective Behavioral Strategies Scale (PBSS)
The PBSS was developed by Martens et al. (2005) as a quan-
titative measure of PBS use to determine the relationship PBS have
with alcohol-related negative consequences and alcohol consump-
tion. Participants are asked to respond to 15 items indicating “the
degree to which you engage in the following behaviors when using
alcohol or ‘partying.’” Higher scores on this measure represent a
greater use of protective strategies, and lower scores mean a lesser
use of protective strategies. Results from an exploratory factor
analysis indicated that a three-factor model best fit the data (Mar-
tens et al., 2005). The factors were Limiting/Stopping Drinking
(LSD; = .81), Manner of Drinking (MOD; = .73), and Serious
Harm Reduction (SHR; = .63). LSD items include “determine
not to exceed a certain number of drinks” and “leave the bar/party
at a predetermined time.” MOD items include “avoid drinking
games” and “drink shots of liquor.” The “drink shots of liquor”
item is the only reverse scored item on the PBSS. SHR items
include “use a designated driver” and “know where your drink has
been at all times.”
Analyses of convergent validity found negative correlations
with consumption variables and negative consequences and mod-
erate correlations between the three PBS factors, suggesting that
they measure related but distinct constructs. Martens, Ferrier, and
Cimini (2007) tested a one-factor, two-factor (Manner of Drinking
including Serious Harm Reduction items and Limiting/Stopping
This article was published Online First February 11, 2013.
Michael B. Madson, Randolph C. Arnau, Sasha J. Lambert, Department
of Psychology, The University of Southern Mississippi.
Sasha J. Lambert is now at the Federal Correctional Complex, Oakdale,
LA.
Correspondence concerning this article should be addressed to Michael
B. Madson, The University of Southern Mississippi, Department of Psy-
chology, 118 College Drive #5025, Hattiesburg, MS 39406-5025. E-mail:
Michael.madson@usm.edu
This document is copyrighted by the American Psychological Association or one of its allied publishers.
This article is intended solely for the personal use of the individual user and is not to be disseminated broadly.
Psychological Assessment © 2013 American Psychological Association
2013, Vol. 25, No. 2, 556 –567 1040-3590/13/$12.00 DOI: 10.1037/a0031788
556